add-on list, regarding nov/oct 08's, discussion thread.

[SunnyJustice]

All early '09 VRs.

[DaDwarf]

I think we need to narrow it down to very rare 09's and 08's first. Before even thinking about adding rare 09's.

@spark, those all have been mentioned i believe

[SunnyJustice]

Top of the list?

[lucky333123]

I do agree with both scarf dogs being and spiderwing moved down - I have seen many scarf dogs around when looking for the bunnies and with new rarity shift it doesn't really make sense to have those pets there.
Chocolate Bun, Lilac Bun, Black Dutch Bun, Grey Dutch Bun - if moving down, then they should stay rather high on the new list, since they are much harder to find then the scarf dogs.
Cobweb Bun, Clockwork Bunny, Marionette Dog, Malk PPS pup, Fireworks PPS - stay
Bumblebee Spider - stay or be moved up. These spiders are hard to find and demand for them is growing (as much as it can grow when speaking of spiders).
Purple Sleipnir: moved up

Unsure about Rose Rat, Dark Wood Dog and Ghost cat

I agree but the Ghost Cat should stay. There is still a very nice demand for it. A few weeks ago or so I trades one for a tinsel lion.

[DaDwarf]

I do agree with both scarf dogs being and spiderwing moved down - I have seen many scarf dogs around when looking for the bunnies and with new rarity shift it doesn't really make sense to have those pets there.
Chocolate Bun, Lilac Bun, Black Dutch Bun, Grey Dutch Bun - if moving down, then they should stay rather high on the new list, since they are much harder to find then the scarf dogs.
Cobweb Bun, Clockwork Bunny, Marionette Dog, Malk PPS pup, Fireworks PPS - stay
Bumblebee Spider - stay or be moved up. These spiders are hard to find and demand for them is growing (as much as it can grow when speaking of spiders).
Purple Sleipnir: moved up

Unsure about Rose Rat, Dark Wood Dog and Ghost cat

Don't forget that the spiders spark of demand due to malk leaving - all malk pets jumped in demand. I have seen nobody searching for a bumblebee and when i had one it took me weeks to trade it off for something from the same line.

@spark ^^, please stop posting pictures. We know what pets are very rare and which aren't, we are here to discuss what is going to be top of the list.

[hellhunt]

Don't forget that the spiders spark of demand due to malk leaving - all malk pets jumped in demand. I have seen nobody searching for a bumblebee and when i had one it took me weeks to trade it off for something from the same line.

I have seen few people looking for them lately, but I have feeling this is some how connected. But when looking for bunnies or trade downs (as usual), I rarely see it and I do have it on my WL. As for malk leaving - I have not noticed demand go up for most of them...maybe just for rarest/oldest.

[lucky333123]

Don't forget that the spiders spark of demand due to malk leaving - all malk pets jumped in demand. I have seen nobody searching for a bumblebee and when i had one it took me weeks to trade it off for something from the same line.

I have seen few people looking for them lately, but I have feeling this is some how connected. But when looking for bunnies or trade downs (as usual), I rarely see it and I do have it on my WL. As for malk leaving - I have not noticed demand go up for most of them...maybe just for rarest/oldest.

I have noticed too. The Elemental cats are highish in demand - my friend is trying to get them and is having trouble because the demand is so high. We might want to wait awhile to see if the demand lowers before dealing with the Malk pets.

[Stephajo]

Don't forget that the spiders spark of demand due to malk leaving - all malk pets jumped in demand. I have seen nobody searching for a bumblebee and when i had one it took me weeks to trade it off for something from the same line.

I have seen few people looking for them lately, but I have feeling this is some how connected. But when looking for bunnies or trade downs (as usual), I rarely see it and I do have it on my WL. As for malk leaving - I have not noticed demand go up for most of them...maybe just for rarest/oldest.

I have noticed too. The Elemental cats are highish in demand - my friend is trying to get them and is having trouble because the demand is so high. We might want to wait awhile to see if the demand lowers before dealing with the Malk pets.

I could be wrong but I've always seen malk elementals as kind of high in demand. It took me about a year and a half to get a full set and I still kinda just got lucky along the way to get them. I haven't really seen much of a spike in demand for malks yet, but I know there are still many who don't know/realize she's leaving and we're also kind of waiting to see if her linearts go away. I think the ones in demand now have always been in demand. Perhaps if/when the lines are retired there will be a bigger spike? My observations anyway

Thanks for putting this together! It's a great idea and I'm thinking it'll make things a lot easier for traders down the line.

[nickjr]

Apologies if someone already mentioned this/if the answer is obvious, but what about the Advent 08 non-holiday-themed rats? (the ones that were originally from April 08 to June 08) they're all VR and roughly the same rarity as the April 08 to June 08 dogs, even if they're in lower demand, since most of the rats went VR about a month before most of the dogs; they also went VR before quite some september and other advent list pets, if that matters any XD;

Or is their demand too low?

Also, what about the rats from September 08, such as the panda rats? (they went VR shortly before the Advent 08 rats and dogs mentioned above) Is their demand also too low?

[Zynphera]

Not sure if these have been mentioned yet, but this pet might be a good idea to add:
-Click
And perhaps the 2011 St.patrick's dragon? c:
Sorry if they've been mentioned already, just woke up and a bit sleepy >.<