The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[viviyan]

Hello, what can I add to this trade to makeit fair? Thankyou in advance!

I would say a few early '09 rares - most likely dogs . I would get a second opinion.

Thank you! Another opinion please?

[siilence]

Is this fair ? What should be added or removed if it isn't fair? Thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Yo784WTuGA

[Solloby]

Is this fair ? What should be added or removed if it isn't fair? Thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Yo784WTuGA

If two nons = a dogtag and nonjewel is a tier above the nons, then they are worth maybe a Plains or Grevy Zebra. Dogtag is worth a Mountain Zebra. And a Sunjewel is worth two Zebras. So technically I think it's spot on.

While I think it's fair, since they are such valuable pets I would get a second opinion anyway.

[captain']

i'll pm this to dadwarf is i don't get a reply c:

okay so, i am holding a QUANTITY auction for my non swirl. but i am having a lot of trouble rating the bids. mainly because i am not that much of an experienced trader and got the non swirl via character design sale. anyway, these are all of the bids so far, and i am in urgent need of help to rate them and of information on what too add to them [quantity advent wise]
any help is really appreciated! it would also be great if anyone would tell me the name of an experienced quantity trader.

these are all of the bids so far, i have tried my best to grade them but i am a failed trader, so its not very good.

trade one

trade two

trade three

trade four

[FurOfHawk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qzW7zAfzkA help?

[Twister in Rage]

i'll pm this to dadwarf is i don't get a reply c:

okay so, i am holding a QUANTITY auction for my non swirl. but i am having a lot of trouble rating the bids. mainly because i am not that much of an experienced trader and got the non swirl via character design sale. anyway, these are all of the bids so far, and i am in urgent need of help to rate them and of information on what too add to them [quantity advent wise]
any help is really appreciated! it would also be great if anyone would tell me the name of an experienced quantity trader.

these are all of the bids so far, i have tried my best to grade them but i am a failed trader, so its not very good.

trade one

trade two

trade three

trade four

First of all, I am not the most experienced quantity trader, and I highly recommend you getting another opinion after this one ^^.

Okay, so in my opinion, number 2 is the worst, and number 1 is the best. Bid number 3 is second with bid number 4 third c:


But none of them are close to fair for the Nonswirl

[neiroh]

Joker + ? = Purple Toxic
I'd like to know because I'm really wanting a Joker.
Also, would it be easy to trade down to it?

[FurOfHawk]

i'll pm this to dadwarf is i don't get a reply c:

okay so, i am holding a QUANTITY auction for my non swirl. but i am having a lot of trouble rating the bids. mainly because i am not that much of an experienced trader and got the non swirl via character design sale. anyway, these are all of the bids so far, and i am in urgent need of help to rate them and of information on what too add to them [quantity advent wise]
any help is really appreciated! it would also be great if anyone would tell me the name of an experienced quantity trader.

these are all of the bids so far, i have tried my best to grade them but i am a failed trader, so its not very good.

trade one

trade two

trade three

trade four

First of all, I am not the most experienced quantity trader, and I highly recommend you getting another opinion after this one ^^.

Okay, so in my opinion, number 2 is the worst, and number 1 is the best. Bid number 3 is second with bid number 4 third c:

agreed

[Grace & Ria]

Is this fair? c:

[viviyan]

Hello, what can I add to this trade to makeit fair? Thankyou in advance!