The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[b-star]

Unless I counted incorrectly (or made an error with the maths, see above for the figures):
Trade 1 is worth about 25 Advents.
Trade 2 is worth about 10/11 Advents.
Trade 3 is worth about 28 Advents.

Your Nonswirl is worth 100 - 165 Advents, seek advice on which calculation for it is most correct (or if I made another error early on, as you can see errors carry very heavily). I would ask for confirmation of the Nonswirl's Advent value before working out what they need to add. But I think Trade 3 is the best, especailly as the balloon dog is a lot easier to trade off than the speckle rat.

I agree, the third trade is the best out of the far, but still quite a far way from the worth of the non.
I would actually say the non is worth about 100-140 high advents/110-155 mid-advents or 140-170 Advents ^^
Though we need a very experienced mass trader to share some thoughts on it :3

[siilence]

I don't know if this belongs here, but which pet has more demand: a dogtag or a moonswirl? Would it be a wise move to trade my dogtag for a moonswirl? (Of course if I added some of my pets, I was just wondering if it would be a wise move demand wise.)
Thank you in advance ^^

[captain']

Unless I counted incorrectly (or made an error with the maths, see above for the figures):
Trade 1 is worth about 25 Advents.
Trade 2 is worth about 10/11 Advents.
Trade 3 is worth about 28 Advents.

Your Nonswirl is worth 100 - 165 Advents, seek advice on which calculation for it is most correct (or if I made another error early on, as you can see errors carry very heavily). I would ask for confirmation of the Nonswirl's Advent value before working out what they need to add. But I think Trade 3 is the best, especailly as the balloon dog is a lot easier to trade off than the speckle rat.

I agree, the third trade is the best out of the far, but still quite a far way from the worth of the non.
I would actually say the non is worth about 100-140 high advents/110-155 mid-advents or 140-170 Advents ^^
Though we need a very experienced mass trader to share some thoughts on it :3

okay, i'll start to rate the bids now.
do you guys know an experienced mass trader? the only one i can think of is tess ...
and i don't think i'll try to get 165 advent for the non-swirl. not many people can afford that.

[do.ggo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... M_vWTJJD3g

How can I make this fair? (PM me if you know)

[BrightPink]

Is this fair?
Please, anyone?

[Solloby]

Unless I counted incorrectly (or made an error with the maths, see above for the figures):
Trade 1 is worth about 25 Advents.
Trade 2 is worth about 10/11 Advents.
Trade 3 is worth about 28 Advents.

Your Nonswirl is worth 100 - 165 Advents, seek advice on which calculation for it is most correct (or if I made another error early on, as you can see errors carry very heavily). I would ask for confirmation of the Nonswirl's Advent value before working out what they need to add. But I think Trade 3 is the best, especailly as the balloon dog is a lot easier to trade off than the speckle rat.

I agree, the third trade is the best out of the far, but still quite a far way from the worth of the non.
I would actually say the non is worth about 100-140 high advents/110-155 mid-advents or 140-170 Advents ^^
Though we need a very experienced mass trader to share some thoughts on it :3

okay, i'll start to rate the bids now.
do you guys know an experienced mass trader? the only one i can think of is tess ...
and i don't think i'll try to get 165 advent for the non-swirl. not many people can afford that.

Tess doesn't trade, she doesn't keep track of pet values.

The people in the Rares List Guide thread will know, I'd wait for their response.

Re the number of advents, have you considered trading your nonswirl for around 3 sorbet level pets, or toxics or something higher up the list, then auctioning those off individually for quantity? It would be a lot more affordable for the bidders, but you get the same result at the end of the day.

[zet137]

Black Advent + ?? = GWJ ?

I'm fine with trading the GWJ for the BA alone (im insane) but if the other person were to add, what would they need to add to make it close to fair?

[Solloby]

Black Advent + ?? = GWJ ?

I'm fine with trading the GWJ for the BA alone (im insane) but if the other person were to add, what would they need to add to make it close to fair?

Nick Unicorn?

The most BAs go for is a sorbet, but I don't think they've gone that high in a while, they are getting red toxics at the moment I think. I don't really pay attention to them. But maybe 2 sorbets and a mid main list pet if you want to accommodate the BA's inflation?

But technically they need to add a pet above the big gap.

[zet137]

Black Advent + ?? = GWJ ?

I'm fine with trading the GWJ for the BA alone (im insane) but if the other person were to add, what would they need to add to make it close to fair?

Nick Unicorn?

The most BAs go for is a sorbet, but I don't think they've gone that high in a while, they are getting red toxics at the moment I think. I don't really pay attention to them. But maybe 2 sorbets and a mid main list pet if you want to accommodate the BA's inflation?

But technically they need to add a pet above the big gap.

Ah, thank you :'D I'm not so great at working the main list so now that I have a GWJ it's a bit daunting trying to figure out how I can trade it for a BA :S

[Pideaux]

Although it's a very rare occasion and not something I would *ever* suggest a BA could go for, I recently received a trade for my BA including a GWJ and Red X so. e.e - I would still say BAs are going around sorbet or a bit less level.