The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Cuspid]

Hello,

is this trade fair? Thanks in advance!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IYfnVbYALg

greets

they are overpaying

That is 100% fair. They are even from the same day.

[BrightPink]

Is this fair?

?

[captain']

okay, out of these two trades a. which one is better and b. how many more advents & rares could be added to make them fair?
trade one - trade two

[b-star]

okay, out of these two trades a. which one is better and b. how many more advents & rares could be added to make them fair?
trade one - trade two

They are both immensly unfair to you, unless i've missed something ^^
The first trade could use about two sorbets and a low toxic or so.
The second would need at least a little more than two sorbets - Get another opinion on this though.

[Solloby]

okay, out of these two trades a. which one is better and b. how many more advents & rares could be added to make them fair?
trade one - trade two

They are both immensly unfair to you, unless i've missed something ^^
The first trade could use about two sorbets and a low toxic or so.
The second would need at least a little more than two sorbets - Get another opinion on this though.

I'd cancel both, neither offer enough to be worth considering. If the other person thinks that's ok to offer then they have no clue about the value of the pet they are asking for and probably won't agree to quadrupling their offer (which would still be unfair to you).

[zet137]

They are both immensly unfair to you, unless i've missed something ^^
The first trade could use about two sorbets and a low toxic or so.
The second would need at least a little more than two sorbets - Get another opinion on this though.

I'd cancel both, neither offer enough to be worth considering. If the other person thinks that's ok to offer then they have no clue about the value of the pet they are asking for and probably won't agree to quadrupling their offer (which would still be unfair to you).

Okay, so I'll admit that I sent one of those trades. But it's for a quantity auction. Immortal is asking how many advents and rares we need to add, not sorbets or toxics or anything.

I'm very happy to add to my bid, and I'm definitely going to, but Immortal is asking for feedback so she can advise us on what we need to add.

Sorry for being a bit snappy, but this happened earlier, too D: Thats why Immortal specified advents and rares, not main list or Septembers.

[QueenTess]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... va_aYPUMGg

Hello! Is this fair?

[Solloby]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20313083&userid=14276&signature=mBh383A6tSFDva_aYPUMGg

Hello! Is this fair?

Very unfair to you, your pet is on the Rares List in the Advent section (Desert Swirl PPS) and is valuable. Their pets are run-of-the-mill 09 rares.

They are both immensly unfair to you, unless i've missed something ^^
The first trade could use about two sorbets and a low toxic or so.
The second would need at least a little more than two sorbets - Get another opinion on this though.

I'd cancel both, neither offer enough to be worth considering. If the other person thinks that's ok to offer then they have no clue about the value of the pet they are asking for and probably won't agree to quadrupling their offer (which would still be unfair to you).

Okay, so I'll admit that I sent one of those trades. But it's for a quantity auction. Immortal is asking how many advents and rares we need to add, not sorbets or toxics or anything.

I'm very happy to add to my bid, and I'm definitely going to, but Immortal is asking for feedback so she can advise us on what we need to add.

Sorry for being a bit snappy, but this happened earlier, too D: Thats why Immortal specified advents and rares, not main list or Septembers.

You need to divide those amounts down into advents then.

For a Nonswirl I'd estimate you need 162 advents, but that's based on the assumption that a sorbet is worth 3 balloon dogs, which may be incorrect. If it is only worth 2 balloon dogs, the Nonswirl would be worth 108 advents.

Edit: Here's the math btw.

2x Advent = 1 Grinner
3x Grinner = 1 Blue Rose?
3x Blue Rose = 1 Balloon Dog
2-3 Balloon Dogs = 1 Sorbet?
3x Sorbet = 1 Nonswirl

Source for some of those calculations

[captain']

They are both immensly unfair to you, unless i've missed something ^^
The first trade could use about two sorbets and a low toxic or so.
The second would need at least a little more than two sorbets - Get another opinion on this though.

I'd cancel both, neither offer enough to be worth considering. If the other person thinks that's ok to offer then they have no clue about the value of the pet they are asking for and probably won't agree to quadrupling their offer (which would still be unfair to you).

Okay, so I'll admit that I sent one of those trades. But it's for a quantity auction. Immortal is asking how many advents and rares we need to add, not sorbets or toxics or anything.

I'm very happy to add to my bid, and I'm definitely going to, but Immortal is asking for feedback so she can advise us on what we need to add.

Sorry for being a bit snappy, but this happened earlier, too D: Thats why Immortal specified advents and rares, not main list or Septembers.

oh i'm so sorry guys! i forgot to add the part about the quantity.

and i have another one to rate.

THIS IS FOR A QUANTITY ADVENT LIST PET AUCTION. don't want people to miss that.

so, out of these three bids, which one is a. the best and b. how many advent list pets should be added to make it fair? i need advice on all three, so that the bidders have something to go on.

trade one - trade two - trade three

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20313083&userid=14276&signature=mBh383A6tSFDva_aYPUMGg

Hello! Is this fair?

this is very unfair to the bottom.

[Solloby]

I'd cancel both, neither offer enough to be worth considering. If the other person thinks that's ok to offer then they have no clue about the value of the pet they are asking for and probably won't agree to quadrupling their offer (which would still be unfair to you).

Okay, so I'll admit that I sent one of those trades. But it's for a quantity auction. Immortal is asking how many advents and rares we need to add, not sorbets or toxics or anything.

I'm very happy to add to my bid, and I'm definitely going to, but Immortal is asking for feedback so she can advise us on what we need to add.

Sorry for being a bit snappy, but this happened earlier, too D: Thats why Immortal specified advents and rares, not main list or Septembers.

oh i'm so sorry guys! i forgot to add the part about the quantity.

and i have another one to rate.

THIS IS FOR A QUANTITY ADVENT LIST PET AUCTION. don't want people to miss that.

so, out of these three bids, which one is a. the best and b. how many advent list pets should be added to make it fair? i need advice on all three, so that the bidders have something to go on.

trade one - trade two - trade three

Unless I counted incorrectly (or made an error with the maths, see above for the figures):
Trade 1 is worth about 25 Advents.
Trade 2 is worth about 10/11 Advents.
Trade 3 is worth about 28 Advents.

Your Nonswirl is worth 100 - 165 Advents, seek advice on which calculation for it is most correct (or if I made another error early on, as you can see errors carry very heavily). I would ask for confirmation of the Nonswirl's Advent value before working out what they need to add. But I think Trade 3 is the best, especailly as the balloon dog is a lot easier to trade off than the speckle rat.