The "Is this a fair trade?" thread [xat chat added]

[hellhunt]

Need help with another item trade - is it fair and if not then how to make it fair
according to items guide: candy bag is late 09 UC, lil monster '10 common, coins are mid '10 UC (each it think, not sure though) and that earring is store item

this bid and this one - fair or not, if not , the by how much(technically and demand vise)
don't think it's fair is it?

[CalicoWolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19903572&userid=6076&signature=q2FD7WY8gbZ_TkcwjvsRWw

Is this fair? thanks!

I believe bottom is overpay. A Red X PPS is Main list, and that was a Pink September.
Get a second opinion, though.

Thank You. Anyone else?

[Chris Redfield]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LxLl-pb5JA
Is this fair?

[.:ｒａｉｎｙ ａｖｅｎｕｅ:.]

Dark Leopard + Purple Batdog = Joker Bunny?

[.muse.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19983403&userid=294779&signature=aJERNjdqyntPLxLl-pb5JA
Is this fair?

Technically the horse is overpay alone, but with its low demand and the roses higher demand, the pps makes it fiar if not just slight overpay.

Rainey, it takes a lot more than that to equal a joker bunny. 3 high Septembers like that are worth a balloon dog.

[RavenclawHobbit]

Please i REALY need to know if this is fair quick...http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... r3ZiriYsVw

Seems a tiny bit unfair to them, because of the dragon's demand and the fact that a lot of the rares on your side are late '09s while some of thiers are earlier.

[jormungandr]

purple sleipnir+ Raven Dog= Seal PPS + rares?

[.:ｒａｉｎｙ ａｖｅｎｕｅ:.]

Rainey, it takes a lot more than that to equal a joker bunny. 3 high Septembers like that are worth a balloon dog.

I thought so, someone just sent me a suggestion with that trade, and I wanted to make sure c: Thank you so much for responding!

[.muse.]

Please i REALY need to know if this is fair quick...http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... r3ZiriYsVw

Seems a tiny bit unfair to them, because of the dragon's demand and the fact that a lot of the rares on your side are late '09s while some of thiers are earlier.

Even with the dragons demand, you are pitting advents against monthlies, and in that case, advents normally win. By looking at just rarities yeah the dragon side is overpay. But looking at overal demand, I would never take that trade seeing as in the long run advents and dogs take priority in most users trades. And advent dogs, those are normally the things that go up in rarity the quickest.

[.muse.]

purple sleipnir+ Raven Dog= Seal PPS + rares?

Add like two mid ish 09 rares and that should be good.