The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Nadine]

Is this a good trade? Or is my cat worth more then the Store dog?

I can't see the trade, make sure that you click "share trade" and then copy that link and paste it here ^^

[elder price]

My apologies! this is the trade.

[lucky333123]

My apologies! this is the trade.

Your cat is worth a lot more than the Store dog

[elder price]

My apologies! this is the trade.

Your cat is worth a lot more than the Store dog

Really? About how much would it be worth, petwise? { Sorry I'm asking so many questions! }

[viviyan]

These three pets PLUS a 08 Very rare Halloween cat, plus Fire and Earth/wind (cant remember) 09 rare elemental cats + what= Joker dog, YEllow Toxic OR PPS dragon??

[melody.]

Was this fair? I have no idea if it was or not. I'm not sure whether that Nick Cake Dog is worth more then the raven dog and Sortics or not....

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _PnlY8C6yw

[Jenn the Psycho]

Was this fair? I have no idea if it was or not. I'm not sure whether that Nick Cake Dog is worth more then the raven dog and Sortics or not....

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _PnlY8C6yw

The nick cake dog and raven would be a fair swap without the sortics c:

sunny; i would try and go to Bad moonlight, if she has any fodder right now, she overpays by quite a bit if im right, but demand is going up, for both of the dogs, id say auction the raven- youd get more bang for your buck.
-Sunnycupcake is sharing control of my computer.

[Celozon]

Was this fair? I have no idea if it was or not. I'm not sure whether that Nick Cake Dog is worth more then the raven dog and Sortics or not....

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _PnlY8C6yw

Unfair to you.

These three pets PLUS a 08 Very rare Halloween cat, plus Fire and Earth/wind (cant remember) 09 rare elemental cats + what= Joker dog, YEllow Toxic OR PPS dragon??

I don't understand. Which cat? And are your trading for Joker + Sorbert OR Joker + PPS Dragon, or are you trading for Joker OR Sorbert OR dragon?

My apologies! this is the trade.

Your cat is worth a lot more than the Store dog :)

Really? About how much would it be worth, petwise? { Sorry I'm asking so many questions! }

Cat woudl be worth 3 or 4 of those store pets. Store pets are worth about a 2010 rare. About 4 2010 rares = a 2009 rare.

[miya.]

Is this fair? I'm really reluctent to accept it considering there asking for most of my rare's >.<

And if I asked for the Punk dog for JUST my Pink Patchy September what would make it fair to me / them?

[elder price]

My apologies! this is the trade.

Your cat is worth a lot more than the Store dog

Really? About how much would it be worth, petwise? { Sorry I'm asking so many questions! }

Cat woudl be worth 3 or 4 of those store pets. Store pets are worth about a 2010 rare. About 4 2010 rares = a 2009 rare.[/quote]

Thank you so much. I will cancel the trade So glad I found this thread again!

Is this fair? I'm really reluctent to accept it considering there asking for most of my rare's >.<

And if I asked for the Punk dog for JUST my Pink Patchy September what would make it fair to me / them?

That actually looks pretty unfair on your side to me. I'm no expert, but that many rares/VR's for the punk dog and the other one? Kinda overboard.