The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Party Poison.]

Would this be a fair bid on my liontail?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QQPG9eaLcA
Thank you in advance

[Swifty98]

Based on rarity AND demand, Is this fair?

If not, is it an overpay to me or to them? I really like the butterfly wolf and I would only trade it if I could get some really good pets for that zebra. {I don't like zebras. I'd probably auction it off.}

Thanks so much, Fearless!

Can I get a second opinion? :3

[Nadine]

Would this be fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NovGq2nfBQ
Thanks ^^

[kaede]

What should I add to make this fair? Thank you!

[f e a r l e s s]

What should I add to make this fair? Thank you!

You can add another rare or high demand uncommon to their side.

[Nadine]

What should I add to make this fair? Thank you!

I'd say another in demand mid '09 uncommon, or remove that and add a late '09 rare :3

[Kuzco]

What should I add to make this fair? Thank you!

I would say at least a couple more late 09 uncommons on their side, or one that's high-demand. This is why I don't often trade below rares for rare pets, because people tend to have a different idea of how many uncommons should make up a rare.

[Nejira]

I need help with this trade: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nFAkhID4cw

Someone sent it to me like this, saying they are new. And I'm afraid it's unfair to them because of the rare bat. I don't want to rip somebody off, especially not some one new ^^'

What can I do to make it fair? Or is it actually fair?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

What should I add to make this fair? Thank you!

I'd say another in demand mid '09 uncommon, or remove that and add a late '09 rare :3

early 2010 rare or so should do

[f e a r l e s s]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lBCF73E-wA