The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[lucky333123]

Is this fair? Also, the pets I'm giving them are all on their wishlist.

Unfair to you but I would get a second opinion

[ChibiWolfie]

Is this fair? Also, the pets I'm giving them are all on their wishlist.

How can I make it fair?

[Party Poison.]

Would an Evil PPS+ an Ice PPS and a Neutral Morality dog be fair to a non jeweled lion tail?

[Chris Redfield]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19474159&userid=294779&signature=83RLBXP-3f47W3ch5C9rxQ
For a Sunback, how would this be rated from 1-6, with 1 being the best?

[Troxey]

Is this even fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19474582&userid=215734&signature=iOzhemutStwBO-cwXidRgA

[Nadine]

Is this fair? Also, the pets I'm giving them are all on their wishlist.

How can I make it fair?

I'd say they need to add at least one mid '09 rare to their side ^^

[typewriter,]

Is this fair? Also, the pets I'm giving them are all on their wishlist.

Unfair to you, but get a second opinion ^^

{ Unfair to you. I would say take out November 2009 rare and add instead about a mid 2010 rare, I'd say. Although, I may be wrong. }

[Flicka]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19474275&userid=9355&signature=p08aVwhZsooMs6zNa0iaNw is this a fair suggestion for an eat me dog?

o.o Very unfair to the eat me, unless I missed something...

What would be fair for it?

[blue.roses]

Does anyone know what needs to be added to a Grevy's Zebra to be fair for a Sunjewel? Thanks!

[Sc7856]

Fair? Please only answer if your good with items. If its not fair, what side and what could be done to make it fair?

Please answer!!!!