The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[cloudstarwolf]

Is this a fair trade?

Thanks in advance!

[Uchuujin]

I'm really awful at value of items. I was sent this trade:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nqEjtld2tQ

And I'm wondering what type of pet I should ask for? Like year, rarity, etc? Just an estimate to give me an idea of what to ask for in return.

[TwilightStallion]

Fair?
Thanks!

Also, what would be the best order for these bids?
This is their order right now.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Also, where should this one go?

Click!

[mochi.]

Is this fair?
Thank you!

.click.

[star star.]

Is this a fair trade?

Thanks in advance!

unfair to you.

[blue.roses]

Is this fair?
Thank you!

.click.

unfair to the top
that '12 rare is worth about 2-3 '11 uncommons, I'd say
at most about a late '10 uncommon
that '09 uncommon is fair too much.

[Ali-AnnT]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17919291&userid=174941&signature=w3ZmkBFBlVidWX7aaoBeew

Hi is this fair?

No, take two of the pets off of your side and it will be. The squid is still only an uncommon....

Okay thanks, x

[snowykay]

How's this?

I think it's a tad bit overpay on their part

Looks okay to me but I'm no expert you may want another opinion.

Thanks! :3 Just one more opinion please?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

How's this?

I think it's a tad bit overpay on their part

Looks okay to me but I'm no expert you may want another opinion. :)

Thanks! :3 Just one more opinion please?

unfair to you
the gap is about a mid september

[snowykay]

I keep getting lots of random trades...how's this?