The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Snorrl]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17907314&userid=290592&signature=jlpL7iGa4zhSMd-dKuOsOA
is this fair?
thanks in advanced

very unfair to you

[.swan.]

Is this a fair trade?

unfair to you

i thought it was fair since BW's are sorda low demad

[Minaethiel]

Input on this one? I'm not so great with the cats vs dogs thing. I know the cat is much earlier than the dog, but would it be a fair trade without the April Fools UR Butterdog?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Is this a fair trade?

unfair to you

i thought it was fair since BW's are sorda low demad

this isnt even fair for a noncoon.
its VERY unfair to the UR butter
and its low demand but it doesnt go for less than its worth

[Northstar.]

Mustard Advent Husky + _________(Red or Green or Blue Android)=Pink Grinner

Would a mustard advent husky plus Android dog be fair/close to fair for a Pink grinner?

I would appreciate an answer.
Thanks everyone.
^_^

[.swan.]

[quote="dobermans rock" http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Md-dKuOsOA
is this fair?
thanks in advanced

very unfair to you[/quote]
thanks any other suggestions

[Minimetoo]

Is this a fair trade?

unfair to you

this isnt even fair for a noncoon.
its VERY unfair to the UR butter
and its low demand but it doesnt go for less than its worth

Yeah, I guess not many people are looking for the BW, but it's still high up on the rares list. ^^ Does anyone know what could be added to even out the trade?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Is this a fair trade?

unfair to you

this isnt even fair for a noncoon.
its VERY unfair to the UR butter
and its low demand but it doesnt go for less than its worth

Yeah, I guess not many people are looking for the BW, but it's still high up on the rares list. ^^ Does anyone know what could be added to even out the trade?

atleast a dogtag

[jubilee.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17907314&userid=290592&signature=jlpL7iGa4zhSMd-dKuOsOA
is this fair?
thanks in advanced

very unfair to you

thanks any other suggestions

Agreed. Extremely unfair to you.

Input on this one? I'm not so great with the cats vs dogs thing. I know the cat is much earlier than the dog, but would it be a fair trade without the April Fools UR Butterdog?

It's fair with the Butterdog, but unfair to you without it.

[.swan.]

accualy they will need to add like another 2-3 advents that's what i think