The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Obius]

Yea I figured that. I'm going to give him a nice edited offer.

[Jean.]

Is this fair?
Edit: Also this?

[Physical-Pancakes]

Is this fair?
Edit: Also this?

It's hard to tell with unknowns but because those are store pets, they are likely end up Very rare, so I'd say probably not.

[Celozon]

Is this fair? (There is 100CS added to the red toxic side)
And you can pretty much ignore the items sice they don't mean much next to the spotted tribal.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LfDYsbvLng

[Snorrl]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213972&userid=299736&signature=YaVe18SY0IeUGnOLDq4WDA
Is this fair and what would be need to be added/removed to make it fair?

[Jean.]

Is this fair?
Edit: Also this?

It's hard to tell with unknowns but because those are store pets, they are likely end up Very rare, so I'd say probably not.

Well the other store pets even VR are only worth '10 rares & i'm offering '09s for the first & in the second, a '10 rare & an alien store pet VR

[EndlessFallingSnow]

Are these trades fair?:

Number 1 {They're giving me the cat, wanting the dog}
Number 2 {They're giving me the horse and rabbit, wanting the items}
Number 3 {They're giving me the rat, butterfly wolf, and horse wanting the 2nd gen dog and and wingless butterfly wolf}
Number 4 {They're giving me the butterfly wolf, cat, rat, and bunny wanting the two items}

[Physical-Pancakes]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213430&userid=37133&signature=kcZs7NQ9MV3pOGdFFNaxxQ

Is that trade unfair? The person I was trying to trade with kept saying 'this trade is very unfair' and 'this is the most unfair trade I've ever seen' no matter how many pets I added, so is it really unfair? (Because if it is I really need help...)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213248&userid=37133&signature=PluZPVeScVItkhCKoh_CIQ
and that one... I need to know if it's unfair too... I think it was but I'm not sure...

[Foi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17197558&userid=140930&signature=9RiBaJE57Tlg41F1_ytMaA
Please & thank you!

Please answer, I am on the other side. ;o

[{Starry Night}]

Are these trades fair?:

Number 1 {They're giving me the cat, wanting the dog}
Number 2 {They're giving me the horse and rabbit, wanting the items}
Number 3 {They're giving me the rat, butterfly wolf, and horse wanting the 2nd gen dog and and wingless butterfly wolf}
Number 4 {They're giving me the butterfly wolf, cat, rat, and bunny wanting the two items}

1. Since the dog had an unknown rarity, it's hard to tell.
2. unfair to them
3. Same as one, unknown rarities.