The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[FluffySoul]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l-n02XD1OQ

Any 2nd opinions? Are they over paying for a rares list pet?

[Spirace]

I need help on a bunch of trade. Many of them include Warrior Cats, which I believe are worth more because of demand, but others do not. Anyway, I'd like to get a few opinions on my trades.

Trades with Warriors:
1. Is this one fair?
2. I've been told this is not fair, but I'd really like a second or third opinion

Trades for 2012 Growing White July rare Easter Bunny:
3. Is this one more fair or...
4. ...Is this one?

Item Trades:
5. Could someone also tell me what the Lilac Wings would be worth?
6. This one is for the same pets

Thanks so much to anyone who can help with these trades!

[Re b e l]

Is this fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fETvAS49Gw

[Hekomi]

I need help on a bunch of trade. Many of them include Warrior Cats, which I believe are worth more because of demand, but others do not. Anyway, I'd like to get a few opinions on my trades.

Trades with Warriors:
1. Is this one fair?
2. I've been told this is not fair, but I'd really like a second or third opinion

Trades for 2012 Growing White July rare Easter Bunny:
3. Is this one more fair or...
4. ...Is this one?

Item Trades:
5. Could someone also tell me what the Lilac Wings would be worth?

Thanks so much to anyone who can help with these trades!

1. Unfair to the cats.
2. Meh... I'd go with unfair to the cats.
3. Fair, if not unfair to the dog.
4. Fair.
5. Unfair to the pets. Lilac wings would be worth a '11 uncommon.

[Spirace]

Thank you so much Hekomi! That totally helps me! Now I can actually accept or cancel. Thanks so much!!!

[Re b e l]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yaBscibR5g

is this fair

[Spirace]

Just one more. Please help if you can! Thanks!!

[Hekomi]

Is this fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fETvAS49Gw

Overpay on the bunny's side.

[Chrissy]

One.
Two.
Three.
Thanks~

[Dalek]

Does anyone know what would make up the gap in worth between the red and blue paragraphs? What about the blue paragraph and the green paragraph? c:
Just wondering, because I'm attempting to get a Punk/Lolita dog, and the only thing I have worth it to give would be an advent of the blue paragraph. I'm just wondering what they would need to add for me to get either dog.

Grey Border Collie, Brown Border Collie, Brown Cookie, Pink Cookie, Dark Grey Tag husky, Vixen, Celestial PPS, Bone PPS, Desert/Orange-swirl PPS, Heart PPS, Light Grey Speckled husky, B&W Pointy-eared Border Collie, Ice Blue Swirl, Blue Flower dog, Purple Star bobtail, Purple Heart/Husky, Mustard Heart/Husky, Cream Advent, Pale Pink/Blue-spotted, Pink Heart, Hollyfox Dog, Boar PPS, Dice PPS, Jeweled Liontail, Nonjewel Liontail


Hyena Bun, Royal Bob Bun, Blue Sorbet Bun, Green Toxic Bun, Pink Balloon Bun, Spotted Tribal Bun, Moonswirl Bun, Dogtag Bun, Heart Advent Bun, CE Galaxy Bun, BMD Bun, Seal Store Dogs, Green Android, White Lolita Dog

Peppermint Eared, Christmas Tree dog, Cream Santa Hat Advent, Red-fronted Holly, Hollyfox cat, Snowflake B-wolf, Candy Cane B-wolf, Elf Rat, Brown Santa Cat, White Santa Cat, Nick Cake Dog, Kiss PPS, Evil PPS, Raven Dog, Patchwork Dog, Flop Blood Dog, Tufted Blood Dog,PPS Cocoon

Grey Mini Husky, Snowflake Lion, Brown Red-String Horse, White Tinsel horse, Rudolph Rat, Santa Rat, Tinsel Lion, Roadkill PPS, Orange, Yellow, Pink Punk Dogs, Yellow, Red, Blue Androids

Thanks in advance! <3

Reposting, if anyone could help me on this, I'd be grateful. c: