The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Saedyn]

Could I get a second opinion on the last 3? And a first opinion on this:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E9w739yIbg

That ducky is popular...

For that new trade, unfair to you. The easter rares aren't worth a whole lot.[/quote]


Thanks! I figured as much considering I believe the ducky was purchased in a bath set and I know I bought the dragon. I apologize for not thanking you sooner.

[Saedyn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/e ... ner=269690
How much do I need to add to make it fair? My side is with the Pink Striped September.

It's linking to the start a trade page when I click it.

[Morphius]

What would need to be added to my side to make it fair?
Thanks in advance

[Inska]

Is a PPS pet really worth two pets of the same month?
Thank you in advance!

[addicted.]

is this fair? (:

[f e a r l e s s]

is this fair? (:

Unfair to you.

Why:

Your pet is a year older
Your pet is an advent
Tess horses are very popular

[addicted.]

is this fair? (:

Unfair to you.

Why:

Your pet is a year older
Your pet is an advent
Tess horses are very popular

thanks. (:

[Doetch]

http://oi46.tinypic.com/28ch6p1.jpg
How much do I need to add to make it fair? My side is with the Pink Striped September.

[addicted.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/e ... ner=269690
How much do I need to add to make it fair? My side is with the Pink Striped September.

wrong link.

[Celozon]

is this fair? (:

Unfair to you.

Why:

Your pet is a year older
Your pet is an advent
Tess horses are very popular

Agreed, unfair to you. But for different reasons. And actually its probably not too far from fair, I've seen that dog go for quite a bit. But yes, your pet is an advent and I havn't seen the malk 2009 staff go for advents yet.

Is a PPS pet really worth two pets of the same month?
Thank you in advance!

Assuming that all the pets are the same rarity (like, the PPS and the two pets fromt hat months are all uncommon) No. PPS pets are more popular and thus worth more, but they aren't worth 2 pets. More like, if the PPS was uncommon, one uncommon from that month and a common from a few months earlier would be fair.