The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[TwilightStallion]

Is this fair?

And if it's unfair to me, would adding one more of the antique dogs (same sort) on their side be fair?

Unfair to them

What should be added?

I don't know if this is in the right thread, but how many Roadkill PPS could I get with these, and how many of these should I send in each trade?

i doubt you could get one with those... the road kill pps is on the rares list so would have to offer something around that level.

Ok, I heard a couple of '09 Rares could get me to the bottom of the Rares list somewhere...Please may I have a second opinion?
Also, same question-how many Roadkill PPS could I get with these two groups combined?
X + X

[Firstborn Dragon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16989977&userid=264793&signature=6jEHsK4HtBoKw4tWcU6RRQ

please help!

i think its way unfair to you but get a second opinion

second opinion??

i disagree, even though the demand for shimas are crazy i dont think thats fair to them.[/quote]


so its unfair to them?[/quote]

Breaking it down...

The WWA is on the bottom half of the 2nd step of the rare list.

Yellow Android, punk dog, - mid advent
Candycane Horse, cobweb bun - low advent

Others aren't on rare list. So it seems unfair to them, unless more of those pets have been added to the rare list.

[RainbowFinch]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16989977&userid=264793&signature=6jEHsK4HtBoKw4tWcU6RRQ

please help!

Unfair to the Winged Wood Angel. I am not good with items and pricing them but the Wood wing is on the main rares list. The pets don't add up that far and the items on top of the pets wouldn't close the gap. Check with someone more experienced with items, but I am pretty sure it is unfair. The demand of the Shima is insane but they still aren't worth the advents.

[Firstborn Dragon]

I don't know if this is in the right thread, but how many Roadkill PPS could I get with these, and how many of these should I send in each trade?

i doubt you could get one with those... the road kill pps is on the rares list so would have to offer something around that level.

Ok, I heard a couple of '09 Rares could get me to the bottom of the Rares list somewhere...Please may I have a second opinion?
Also, same question-how many Roadkill PPS could I get with these two groups combined?
X + X[/quote]

Looking what you have there, I would guess you'd be lucky to have enough for 1. Some of those pets aren't in high demand at all, so wouldn't be worth enough. Owls, rats, and spiders are not as valued as other pets which drops their value.

[Flicka]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WvBvU2IWhg any ideas on what I should add?

[Rainpelt]

Hello ^^


Would someone be able to tell me if these two were fair for a blue rose? And if not, what should I add?

Thanks in advance!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16984341&userid=277597&signature=kv0Bb8WWC08NX3XzHdtcHA

I think I should add something, but I don't know what. Could someone help me?

Red Rose = BMD = Sunjewel Bunny = Light Pawprint Rat = Light Heart Rat = Flower/Toxic Rat
Pink Striped September = Pink Patchy September = Winged Blood Dog
Scarf PPS
Target Dog
Light Leopard = Grinners = Halloween Cat = Skelebun

That's the rare list, so it's not a huge difference between the two. I'd guess a 09 uc maybe? Not too sure of how the value between levels works on the rare list steps.

actually there is a huge difference. please dont spread false advice like that.
an uncommon wouldnt fix that in the least.
around 2-3 mid advents should be added.

[Flicka]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WvBvU2IWhg any ideas on what I should add?

[blue.roses]

?? BMD for Heart PPS + Green Grinner + Teal Butterbun ??

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16989977&userid=264793&signature=6jEHsK4HtBoKw4tWcU6RRQ

please help!

Unfair to the Winged Wood Angel. I am not good with items and pricing them but the Wood wing is on the main rares list. The pets don't add up that far and the items on top of the pets wouldn't close the gap. Check with someone more experienced with items, but I am pretty sure it is unfair. The demand of the Shima is insane but they still aren't worth the advents.

the bottom adds up to at the very most a red rose.
so unfair to the woodwing.