The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[cookies.]

Its for Nepphy.

[vvoland]

Its for Nepphy.

Then that is completely false advice.

Help? :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hY9h2a8XAw
I know this is overpay, but they payed a zebra for it too. Does anyone have an idea of what I can add to overpay more than that?

[cookies.]

Its for Nepphy.

Then that is completely false advice.

Help? :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hY9h2a8XAw
I know this is overpay, but they payed a zebra for it too. Does anyone have an idea of what I can add to overpay more than that?

-.-' i am just giving my advice. I dont really need other comments for it.

[Silverstar]

Its for Nepphy.

Then that is completely false advice.

Help? :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hY9h2a8XAw
I know this is overpay, but they payed a zebra for it too. Does anyone have an idea of what I can add to overpay more than that?

A high Rares List pet? xD
Demand-wise it's unfair to Coontail, Zebras goes for Nonjewels.

[Pideaux]

Its for Nepphy.

Then that is completely false advice.

Help? :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hY9h2a8XAw
I know this is overpay, but they payed a zebra for it too. Does anyone have an idea of what I can add to overpay more than that?

I'm not sure what you mean? Anything else that you add to your side would be an overpay as the Zebra is already an overpayment alone. e.e - With the sheer rarity of the Zebra, I wouldn't swap it for anything less than a coontail personally. low demand or not.

['Possum]

Its for Nepphy.

Then that is completely false advice.

Help? :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hY9h2a8XAw
I know this is overpay, but they payed a zebra for it too. Does anyone have an idea of what I can add to overpay more than that?

-.-' i am just giving my advice. I dont really need other comments for it.

Your advice is WRONG and is not wanted, needed, or even allowed here when it's blatantly wrong and going to get someone to accept a bad trade.
Please learn your rarities before offering advice on things you know nothing about! D:<

[Swiftkill_]

Is this fair? ^^
If no, what should be added and to wich side?
Thanks.

[Tybalt]

Is this fair? ^^
If no, what should be added and to wich side?
Thanks.

Unfair to bottom, the rat is a re-release.

I'm not sure what they should add, possibly a couple more 2012 rares?

[Pideaux]

Is this fair? ^^
If no, what should be added and to wich side?
Thanks.

Unfair to you. Two 2012 rares are never going to be worth a 09 rare. ouo b - I'm not exactly certain what else they should add but if it were my trade, I wouldn't feel comfortable with anything less than a late 2009 non-dog rare or a early 2010 dog or non-dog rare. e.e Get a second opinion though. If you're looking for the worth of the rat in Easter rares, I would personally say something like 7-10 per 09 rare non-dog. e.e - But I'm one of the few people that values 09s fairly. Most people would swap their 09 non-dog for a couple easter rares like that. Woo for cheating yourself out OUO

[Solarizing]

Is this fair? x'D

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4oiWGb3vdg