The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

How about this? I really cinfused to edit really >.<

still unfair to you, they should add about an early 2011

they would need a late-mid 2010 uncommon.

[Joe Kerr]

Fair? If not, what could be added?

[ScuroFenice]

(Whenever I try to post the links it doesn't work out very well, so I am going to post what the trade is if that's ok.)

They will give me:

2


I will give them:
1

Is this fair? If not what could be added?

I think this is unfair

This is extremely unfair to you, one, it's a warrior cat, and two, it's from 2009 and the dog is from 2012

[iHeartOnHoliday]

How about this? I really cinfused to edit really >.<

still unfair to you, they should add about an early 2011

Take off the items. The 2010 Uncommon is enough for the two 2011 Uncommons.

[Windi_1]

(Whenever I try to post the links it doesn't work out very well, so I am going to post what the trade is if that's ok.)

They will give me:

2


I will give them:
1

Is this fair? If not what could be added?

I think this is unfair

That is hugely, hugely unfair to the bottom

Very unfair to the warrior cat. The warrior cats still have a big demand on them...aside from the fact that they're d/c and not adoptable anymore except for events and Advents.

[Mitziko]

How about this? I really cinfused to edit really >.<

still unfair to you, they should add about an early 2011

How about this? I really cinfused to edit really >.<

still unfair to you, they should add about an early 2011

WOW tahnkyou for the answer. really I cant distinguish between fair and not, -_-" little silly

[Lovely Radiance]

(Whenever I try to post the links it doesn't work out very well, so I am going to post what the trade is if that's ok.)

They will give me:

2


I will give them:
1

Is this fair? If not what could be added?

This is very unfair because the dog was released 2012-03-19. The cat was released 2010-02-06. So either more needs to be added on their side, possibly 3 uncommons ( or 1 rare + 1 uncommon) from at least 2012 or 2011 in order for this to be fair.

[scorps]

How about this? I really cinfused to edit really >.<

still unfair to you, they should add about an early 2011

they would need a late-mid 2010 uncommon.

yes sorry i just saw, i thought the date said october (10) not january (1) :3

[Joe Kerr]

Fair? If not, what could be added?

[writingrules]

(Whenever I try to post the links it doesn't work out very well, so I am going to post what the trade is if that's ok.)

They will give me:

2


I will give them:
1

Is this fair? If not what could be added?

I think this is unfair

This is extremely unfair to you, one, it's a warrior cat, and two, it's from 2009 and the dog is from 2012

I thought so, I just wanted to get an opinion before I told the user that. Thank you both!

Very unfair to the warrior cat. The warrior cats still have a big demand on them...aside from the fact that they're d/c and not adoptable anymore except for events and Advents.

Thank you for the help!

No I just have to edit it and try to make it fair.

~WR