The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Zappique]

april malk dragon for a joker, if unfair, what should be added?

[HaloFire]

nonjewel, purple ur horse, bmd, scarf pps and plain white dog for coontail plus some store money.

[Deidara's Girl]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=2385904

How many CS $ is this pet worth? Give me a range. Someone is buying items for me in return for this pet, but neither of us know how much it's worth! ^^!

I need an anwser AY-SAP!!!

[Jeweled]

april malk dragon for a joker, if unfair, what should be added?

Personally, I don't think the dragon is worth a joker, but I've seen them going for more. Keeping that in mind the trade is ok but if I were the joker side I would not do it. Px

nonjewel, purple ur horse, bmd, scarf pps and plain white dog for coontail plus some store money.

The Non jewel side is overpaying. C:

['Possum]

Yeah. I don't think the Dragon is worth a Joker. Especially since Malk has repeatedly said that these Dragons will continue to be released and therefore go down in value over time. The Joker is extremely sought after and will only go UP in value as time goes on since it won't be released again.

I've got a huge question... I've managed to narrow the offers in my NonJewel auction down to these three. Now I don't know what to do with them. Which one, if any is the best offer? I'm having a hard time since I tend to listen to my heart which likes certain things despite the value or lack of. *bangs head slowly and repeatedly against keyboard*

OFFER 1~~Yellow Sorbet and Rainbow Mane

OFFER 2~~ These Plus White Dragon, Rare Pink Advent Horse, Valentines Lion, PPS Malk Draft, Camouflage Dog Tag.

OFFER 3~~Any and all pets from this group Plus Red X PPS, red dragon, and nick b-day dog + 10 From Here

[CalicoWolf]

Need quick answer:

I'm trading the strawberry dog and strawberry pps FOR the uncommon unicorn of my wishlist and the two april store pets, compleate set of the easter hunt pups. Is that fair?

I think it's unfair to the Strawberry Set. I could be wrong though..

I have had 3-4 people say thats unfair, What should be added? Howis it unfair?

[Jeweled]

Yeah. I don't think the Dragon is worth a Joker. Especially since Malk has repeatedly said that these Dragons will continue to be released and therefore go down in value over time. The Joker is extremely sought after and will only go UP in value as time goes on since it won't be released again.

I've got a huge question... I've managed to narrow the offers in my NonJewel auction down to these three. Now I don't know what to do with them. Which one, if any is the best offer? I'm having a hard time since I tend to listen to my heart which likes certain things despite the value or lack of. *bangs head slowly and repeatedly against keyboard*

OFFER 1~~Yellow Sorbet and Rainbow Mane

OFFER 2~~ These Plus White Dragon, Rare Pink Advent Horse, Valentines Lion, PPS Malk Draft, Camouflage Dog Tag.

OFFER 3~~Any and all pets from this group Plus Red X PPS, red dragon, and nick b-day dog + 10 From Here

The first is the best but none are anywhere near worth a non jewel. ^^;

[Lady Kiba]

I've got a huge question... I've managed to narrow the offers in my NonJewel auction down to these three. Now I don't know what to do with them. Which one, if any is the best offer? I'm having a hard time since I tend to listen to my heart which likes certain things despite the value or lack of. *bangs head slowly and repeatedly against keyboard*

OFFER 1~~Yellow Sorbet and Rainbow Mane

OFFER 2~~ These Plus White Dragon, Rare Pink Advent Horse, Valentines Lion, PPS Malk Draft, Camouflage Dog Tag.

OFFER 3~~Any and all pets from this group Plus Red X PPS, red dragon, and nick b-day dog + 10 From Here

I personally like offer 2 the best. But I really love the balloon dogs, so i might be a tad biased.

['Possum]

The first is the best but none are anywhere near worth a non jewel. ^^;

That's what I was afraid of.

I personally like offer 2 the best. But I really love the balloon dogs, so i might be a tad biased.

I know. I'm seeing all these Doggies that I really really like and just needed an unbiased opinion based on value instead of how much I love the specific pets being offered.

So, what should be added to any of the offers to make them more fair? Other than the NonTag I was desperately looking for that nobody seems to have or want to give up if they do have it.

[Jeweled]

The first is the best but none are anywhere near worth a non jewel. ^^;

That's what I was afraid of.

I personally like offer 2 the best. But I really love the balloon dogs, so i might be a tad biased.

I know. I'm seeing all these Doggies that I really really like and just needed an unbiased opinion based on value instead of how much I love the specific pets being offered.

So, what should be added to any of the offers to make them more fair? Other than the NonTag I was desperately looking for that nobody seems to have or want to give up if they do have it.

The first offer is worth a sorbet and say, line tribal, so they'd need to add two more common/mid-range Augusts or one rare one like the BE galaxy or spotted tribal.