The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[_Serenity_]

I'm kind of doubting it, but does this seem fair?

Click!

This one is iffy. Value wise it is unfair to you. The store pet is only worth 1 2010 Rare, the other pet is of course an uncommon. Demand wise, perhaps not due to the fact of the low value of the Draft horses, and the PPS pony is valuable- but I am unsure if it is worth a Rare( not too sure with ponies ). Honestly in my opinion I would say unfair, but please feel free to wait for another opinion.

Looking for a second opinion?

[Night <3]

I'm not sure on this one, so I'm coming here for help!

Unfair to Cerberus.

[TigressJaguiar]

I'm kind of doubting it, but does this seem fair?

Click!

This one is iffy. Value wise it is unfair to you. The store pet is only worth 1 2010 Rare, the other pet is of course an uncommon. Demand wise, perhaps not due to the fact of the low value of the Draft horses, and the PPS pony is valuable- but I am unsure if it is worth a Rare( not too sure with ponies ). Honestly in my opinion I would say unfair, but please feel free to wait for another opinion.

Well, The Drafts are low in demand, yet they are both Rares from 2010. And the newest Store Dogs are pretty high in demand, but I think a Draft would be able to get a Store dog. About the PPS, that is slightly unfair to you. you should probably offer a medium-high demand Uncommon of the same year, altough, a Draft might work. As Hloydn said, it matters on your opinion.

And what do you think of this? For 20 C$?

[Ceese]

Is this better?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MUEF6Q-Vkg

[Kalid]

I'm wanting to trade my purple star(on advent rares list) for a malk staff dog. There is a big difference in rarities, so I'm not sure what else to ask for in addition. This is what I'm considering asking, please tell me if it would be over or underpay if they say yes. If it is under, they have the red/orange malk '09 UC I could ask for too. Please let me know.

The trade is here

[MadHattersRevenge]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DwG6O8uGCQ
is this fair?
what could make it fair? thank you!

[asta,]

I normally don't come here anymore, but I was curious on the trade below?

Click please. ^-^

[c h r i s t m a s]

I normally don't come here anymore, but I was curious on the trade below?

Click please. ^-^

I think its unfair to you

[Law]

I normally don't come here anymore, but I was curious on the trade below?

Click please. ^-^

I think its unfair to you

Is the St. Patty's day dog worth more than the peppermint bun on the rares list? If not, it was unfair to bottom.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

I normally don't come here anymore, but I was curious on the trade below?

Click please. ^-^

I think its unfair to you

the bunny alone is worth more than their dog