The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Noel]

Can't see the trade.

That's strange, I'm sure I used the share trade link.
But it's been edited anyways. What about this? For a Raven Dog.

[KenmilltoSky]

July PPS & A Purple Toxic for a UR Butterfly Wolf?

Thanks in advance. :3

[4kcuo]

Can't see the trade.

That's strange, I'm sure I used the share trade link.
But it's been edited anyways. What about this? For a Raven Dog.

Unfair to the Raven Dog.

[⚜✧ Chichi ✧⚜]

my:
for
their:
is it fair?

[~ dawn ~]

According to the following scale what would thisbid rank?
Ranking System
Bid will be rank on a 1-6 basis.
1- You definitely need to add more, sorry
2- You could add a few more pets
3- Looks almost fair; try adding one or two more pets
4- Great Bid
5- Awesome Bid
6- I must accept this now or I will DIE

[palmsprout]

Is this unfair to one of the sides?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IrdvLm-2Hw
If so, does anyone know what needs to be added/removed? c:

[Celozon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=14935549&userid=223744&signature=oMTcn-DtWZpqq6CFmPIEpQ

Unfair to you.

Actually the PPS b-wolf is worth a mid-advent last I checked. Its fair.

Unfair to the top.

So the single dog bid is better then the other? O:

no, I'd say the trade is better (sorry I got a bit confused before, I thought it was you offering the dog for the trade >.> , not both being offer to you)

Can't see the trade.

That's strange, I'm sure I used the share trade link.
But it's been edited anyways. What about this? For a Raven Dog.

Unfair to the Raven Dog.

It's close but I'd agree, unfair to the raven dog.

According to the following scale what would thisbid rank?
Ranking System
Bid will be rank on a 1-6 basis.
1- You definitely need to add more, sorry
2- You could add a few more pets
3- Looks almost fair; try adding one or two more pets
4- Great Bid
5- Awesome Bid
6- I must accept this now or I will DIE

I'd say #3. The Pocky is worth a '08 rare and some '09 rares. But you may want a second opinion.

[squid!]

more fair to us?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8XnZYyqFAw

or


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kZJrFfqLhA

or

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tutekxt0yw

[~ dawn ~]

According to the following scale what would this bid rank?
Ranking System
Bid will be rank on a 1-6 basis.
1- You definitely need to add more, sorry
2- You could add a few more pets
3- Looks almost fair; try adding one or two more pets
4- Great Bid
5- Awesome Bid
6- I must accept this now or I will DIE

I'd say #3. The Pocky is worth a '08 rare and some '09 rares. But you may want a second opinion.

Thanks
Second opinion please

[Celozon]

more fair to us?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8XnZYyqFAw

or


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kZJrFfqLhA

or

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tutekxt0yw

I'm not sure if they are fair or not but I'd say the third one is best, and the first is second best.