The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Sulli]

- http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q_FCOSR8Ag
Is this fair? Thanks in advance. ^^

[Strangeness]

I need help deciding which bids are fair. Could someone please help me? Thank you in advance!
Trade 1
Trade 2
~Snowcone

[Law]

I need help deciding which bids are fair. Could someone please help me? Thank you in advance!
Trade 1
Trade 2
~Snowcone

Unfair to you
Unfair to them

[Morticia]

Which one of these is fair?
Trade 1
Trade 2
Thanks for any help ^^

Also:
Flop-eared Pink September for Cake Dog.
What does the Pink September need to add?

Trade one is not fair to the top. Trade two is fair. I cannot help you with the bottom though, 08s are not my thing CX

Agreed, and for the last they need to add around a common '08 rare, perhaps that plus an '09 rare. =3

Ok, thank you both <3
One more opinion on both please? ^^

[rickith]

I'd like to confirm (or perhaps refute) my suspicions, is this fair? Please only answer if you're absolutely sure.

Unfair to the Red Toxic.

Thanks, I wondered. xD What do you think I should add? ^^

Anyone, please? =3 Even a rough estimate would be helpful at this point! xD

[pikachu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=14449509&userid=130793&signature=CufGyQaOzJDDMl5qkg4Fzw

Is this fairr.?
-M.M<33

I disagree. the pps dragon is only a few slots under the balloon on the rares list. and its not a huge gap. I always though it was a low-mid september to the balloon. the cake dog would be a bit too much in my opinion.

Okaay thanks to everyone who hellped.! Can an one give me any advice on how i should edit it or add or something.<33 Thanks so much. You've been really helpful.
-M.M<33

Hmm
I'd just accept it because cake dogs aren't in any demand really. But that's just me. ouo

[Jenn the Psycho]

Which one of these is fair?
Trade 1
Trade 2
Thanks for any help ^^

Also:
Flop-eared Pink September for Cake Dog.
What does the Pink September need to add?

Trade one is not fair to the top. Trade two is fair. I cannot help you with the bottom though, 08s are not my thing CX

Agreed, and for the last they need to add around a common '08 rare, perhaps that plus an '09 rare. =3[/quote]

Ok, thank you both <3
One more opinion on both please? ^^

[/quote]

Actually, I'd say a low-mid advent or so should be added to make it fair to a cake dog :3
There is a bit of a gap between them seen here in the septembers list ^^

[Fjäll Räven]

Um is this fair???
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dfqNHtNdng

[♥Sterek♥]

Hello, could somebody tell me if either of these trades are fair?
Trade 1
Trade 2
Thank you so much :3
~Monty♥

Both are quite unfair to you

Agreed.

No about the second one there aren't a lot high rare list pets that defenetly unfair to u but I m not good with items so I don't know 1

[Ava_Ria]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1SEwrVBVjg

What do you think of this one? Half the pets on there I would really like to get, but I feel like 11 pets for 4 store pets isn't all that fair. I don't know whether to accept because I want the pets she's offering, or to cancel/edit back and ask for more.

*note: I have already edited her first offer and asked for more pets and she dropped it back down to 11, so that's why I don't know if she would give anything more*