The "Is this a fair trade?" thread -Rule Update-

[Horror]

Is this a fair offer? I don't want to offer too little D:

If we value 2 same rarity pets as one higher rarity (at least for UCs and below) then you're overpaying a bit.
About 2 '17 uncommons would be fair.

[Scarlet Janefox]

Is this a fair offer? I don't want to offer too little D:

You're massively overpaying; just one of the uncommons would be fair for their common.

[breakerbeam]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=63080210

fair trade?

[_+TuxedoCat+_]

This doesn't look at all fair to me, am I missing something??

[piggie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63080210

fair trade?

Wrong link. Use the [Share trade] link instead c:

[Horror]

This doesn't look at all fair to me, am I missing something??

Looks pretty much fair going by the 3 month rule^
Both sides are only worth about 3 09 rares

[pigeon -]

This doesn't look at all fair to me, am I missing something??

it would be a fair trade c:

the '08 dog was extended release until summer of '09 so is 99.5% of
the time valued at it's mid '09 date and the green dog is from '09 as well c:

[Eagle's Eye]

ignore the white feb please
Would you recommend me taking this? Why or why not?
And roughly what's the value gap between those two?

[NicoKitten]

Is this fair to my rose PPS? On 1-10 scale how good of a bid is it? (How's the demand of the rat?

Can someone please help? This is the fourth page, i only want one or two responses.

[Eagle's Eye]

ignore the white feb please
Would you recommend me taking this? Why or why not?
And roughly what's the value gap between those two?