The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[hoss-sauce11]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108394308&userid=920989&signature=orM4L0sWSxBDSg467kdgTw

is this trade fair? I also got another trade with the same 2016 winged dog and 100 c$ for my sakura dog,,

I really wanna help them out but I love this dog so TvT unless it's really good for me and I could use what I get to get another sakura dog then I don't rlly wanna do it..

boop

[keayi]

Looking for help on these two trades

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108392574&userid=81393&signature=v7feK2Tg0jWhp9a9VnTbEg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108429570&userid=81393&signature=txYYF_mIwjtZWE3F7FOgmQ

Thank you!

1) Not sure but the Smiley (0,5 MA) and warrior (0,5 MA) seem to be worth more than their entire side UNLESS the rerelease VRs on the opposite are all '09 VRs = 6 '09 R which is the low end of 1 MA. I know the Tess horse is a '09 VR but I'm unsure about the bunnies.

2) I found the rat (Block Stripe Rat) at 1 MA, and its littermates sit at the bottom of '08 Basic (former) VRs. So it's safe to say it probably trades between a 0,5-1 MA.. The warrior is worth a solid 0,5 MA, so this is probably fair-ish.
They're technically overpaying slightly if we are just looking at base-values but maybe bc rats have poor demand yk

:oops:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108394308&userid=920989&signature=orM4L0sWSxBDSg467kdgTw

is this trade fair? I also got another trade with the same 2016 winged dog and 100 c$ for my sakura dog,,

I really wanna help them out but I love this dog so TvT unless it's really good for me and I could use what I get to get another sakura dog then I don't rlly wanna do it..

boop

You're probably safer keeping the Sakura in that case, because their side seems to be worth maybe 0,75 MA and the Sakura is a solid 1 MA.

Flyig Dog = 0,5 MA
'21 Store Peacock = '10 R = 0,5-1 '09 R
'09 VR = ~2 '09 R

[The Lady Amalthea]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108444084&userid=938809&signature=rW7hPtnd2ZfyIB7aYTQ-ng

Is this fair? The spiders are the most wanted by the other person we are trying to balance out a fair trade for the lioness

[zangoose 97]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108442524&userid=575665&signature=MU-_-WF2FFFW5J0ML0swZQ

Hello, is this fair? Would it be fair if I offered the full store pet set without the horse?

I *believe* '21 store pets are considered to be valued at a '10 rare each. (I personally tend to value store pets higher than "official" values.) Plus, store pets have good demand, while demand for spiders isn't great (I don't believe this one has any special demand, but feel free to get a second opinion.) Personally, I'd offer two of the store pets *at most.*

Thank you! Could I get a second opinion?

[hoss-sauce11]

:oops:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108394308&userid=920989&signature=orM4L0sWSxBDSg467kdgTw

is this trade fair? I also got another trade with the same 2016 winged dog and 100 c$ for my sakura dog,,

I really wanna help them out but I love this dog so TvT unless it's really good for me and I could use what I get to get another sakura dog then I don't rlly wanna do it..

boop

You're probably safer keeping the Sakura in that case, because their side seems to be worth maybe 0,75 MA and the Sakura is a solid 1 MA.

Flyig Dog = 0,5 MA
'21 Store Peacock = '10 R = 0,5-1 '09 R
'09 VR = ~2 '09 R

[/quote]

ty! (ik i f'd up the quote ignore that lmao)

[abbeycatwolf]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108436557&userid=691941&signature=QqcPrXfx8AbcV2CU-Rg6zQ

wondering what the worth of token pets are before the rarity is released?

[WisteriaDragon]

No rares here, but wondering about these older staff pets:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108443775&userid=526141&signature=Wl2piKBmeZ5tn94OLoEB3g

[The Last Raven]

Looking for help on these two trades

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108392574&userid=81393&signature=v7feK2Tg0jWhp9a9VnTbEg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108429570&userid=81393&signature=txYYF_mIwjtZWE3F7FOgmQ

Thank you!

1) Not sure but the Smiley (0,5 MA) and warrior (0,5 MA) seem to be worth more than their entire side UNLESS the rerelease VRs on the opposite are all '09 VRs = 6 '09 R which is the low end of 1 MA. I know the Tess horse is a '09 VR but I'm unsure about the bunnies.

2) I found the rat (Block Stripe Rat) at 1 MA, and its littermates sit at the bottom of '08 Basic (former) VRs. So it's safe to say it probably trades between a 0,5-1 MA.. The warrior is worth a solid 0,5 MA, so this is probably fair-ish.
They're technically overpaying slightly if we are just looking at base-values but maybe bc rats have poor demand yk

Thank you so much for your help!

I have a new trade.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108436451&userid=81393&signature=cc2-QBGep9j83pQF1ZTEmQ

[lapdog]

hi, how does this look?
thanks for help in advance! <3

[Mr. Grizz]

Could someone please help? I do not do trades too often.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108437550&userid=29835&signature=uOJqpTsfaUwYaf4onY9mdQ