The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Mosstail<3]

nope, it also has to be rare. That was unfair.

Alright then, I'll keep that in mind for next time. Thank you!

Nuuuuuu, WAIT! That's not entirely true! DON' GO.

It's not? *is more confused*

Oh, and would this be fair?

I figured since the Butterwolf is a year older than the dog, it should be fair....right?[/quote]
nope not fair...

[Soupalicious]

Sounds good, thank you moonstruck! I think I'll need to stalk this thread for a bit longer to get a better hang on the finer side of trading xD

[Mosstail<3]

Fair?
I have no idea with these items. Thanks!

unfair to the person getting the one dog! not fair at all.

[bear]

nope, it also has to be rare. That was unfair.

Alright then, I'll keep that in mind for next time. Thank you!

Nuuuuuu, WAIT! That's not entirely true! DON' GO.

It's not? *is more confused*

Oh, and would this be fair?

I figured since the Butterwolf is a year older than the dog, it should be fair....right?[/quote]

For the trade, yeah I think its fair.

[bear]

Fair?
I have no idea with these items. Thanks!

unfair to the person getting the one dog! not fair at all.

Other opinions?

[tawnypelt3]

nope, it also has to be rare. That was unfair.

Alright then, I'll keep that in mind for next time. Thank you!

Nuuuuuu, WAIT! That's not entirely true! DON' GO.

It's not? *is more confused*

Oh, and would this be fair?

I figured since the Butterwolf is a year older than the dog, it should be fair....right?[/quote]

Oh. You came back. Anyway... NO. Is most definitely not fair. The butterdog is in demand, but its worth isn't very high (despite the ridiculous overpay some people demand for it >->). Those BWs aren't exactly high in demand (not anymore, anyway), but one of them is still more valuable than the silly butterdog. I wouldn't give more than, maybe... 3-5 late 2011 uncommons. At MOST two mid-2011 uncommons.

EDIT: It took way too long to get this posted. Get getting ninja'ed by new posts. >.<

[Soupalicious]

Oh, and would this be fair?

I figured since the Butterwolf is a year older than the dog, it should be fair....right?

Oh. You came back. Anyway... NO. Is most definitely not fair. The butterdog is in demand, but its worth isn't very high (despite the ridiculous overpay some people demand for it >->). Those BWs aren't exactly high in demand (not anymore, anyway), but one of them is still more valuable than the silly butterdog. I wouldn't give more than, maybe... 3-5 late 2011 uncommons. At MOST two mid-2011 uncommons.

EDIT: It took way too long to get this posted. Get getting ninja'ed by new posts. >.<

So the butterwolf would be overpay for the butterdog? Alright, I'll think about the trade a bit more before I send it in.
Thank you for all your help Tawnypelt, you've been so helpful!Sorry to be so clueless with all of this demand rarity xD

[Moonstruck Muse]

Fair?
I have no idea with these items. Thanks!

unfair to the person getting the one dog! not fair at all.

Other opinions?

I'm not good with VRs, just as a disclaimer, but this seems like overpay for the one dog, for my two cents. I'd see if anyone else has any ideas though, since I'm not really confident in my judgement on this one.

[alfiq]

Fair?
I have no idea with these items. Thanks!

I'd say fair, considering that both the grey dragon and the angel advent are just under the BA.
They also added quite the amount of rares, so yes, seems fair too me.

[bear]

Fair?
I have no idea with these items. Thanks!

I'd say fair, considering that both the grey dragon and the angel advent are just under the BA.
They also added quite the amount of rares, so yes, seems fair too me.

Thanks c: