The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Silphy]

Any opinion before I accept? (:
Oh, this too X

To be honest. I would totally accept that trade.

Okay, thank you! Any second opinions?

[Hauntednightmares]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63467277&userid=867096&signature=_vQcyjhkzE0uzVi9f0gtdA

Please reply quick. What should I take away?[/quote]

[.crossfire.]

how is this?
would you take it demand-wise?

They are overpaying. The horse would technically be fair, but if your looking for overpay, then the storepet works. Depends on how you and your partner value the pets

[Hauntednightmares]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63466960&userid=867096&signature=C4-thOb9XXH_WT5QetWxzg

Was this fair?

[.crossfire.]

Any opinion before I accept? (:

To be honest. I would totally accept that trade.

Please be more descriptive when replying.

Personally, I wouldn't. The bee isn't too bed with demand, but I've never seen it go for its true value. Correct me if I'm wrong, And I've also been told the Malk has a semi-poor demand. I think your better off with your tiger.

(Please get another opinion)

[pink]

how is this?
would you take it demand-wise?

They are overpaying. The horse would technically be fair, but if your looking for overpay, then the storepet works. Depends on how you and your partner value the pets

I disagree. I've seen those store pets go for multiple 09 rares especially that one. It's unfair to them, especially since horses have a bad demand. Once again it depends on how much you like and value the pet but it is unfair to you.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63467277&userid=867096&signature=_vQcyjhkzE0uzVi9f0gtdA

Please reply quick. What should I take away?

You are only supposed to make one post per page.

[zenzi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63467277&userid=867096&signature=_vQcyjhkzE0uzVi9f0gtdA

Please reply quick. What should I take away?

personally i feel that one of the punk dogs or the red rose would be a good swap for the marionette.
this seems like quite a big rip off.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63466960&userid=867096&signature=C4-thOb9XXH_WT5QetWxzg

Was this fair?

unfair to you
the gap between the coontail and the phoenix is two sorbs or a spotted tribal, the advents and septs don't add up close to that unfortunately

[zenzi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63467595&userid=863039&signature=7HiseytDm1Y3fnBaCQoZyg

I know this trade is very unfair, but I really need help! I need to know how much I need to add! (much noobish)

roughly an '10 rare + '11 rare + '12 rare would have to be added.

[Silphy]

Any opinion before I accept? (:

To be honest. I would totally accept that trade.

Please be more descriptive when replying.

Personally, I wouldn't. The bee isn't too bed with demand, but I've never seen it go for its true value. Correct me if I'm wrong, And I've also been told the Malk has a semi-poor demand. I think your better off with your tiger.

(Please get another opinion)

Alright. Any third opinion? ^^"

[spacecatmint]

Any opinion before I accept? (:

To be honest. I would totally accept that trade.

Please be more descriptive when replying.

Personally, I wouldn't. The bee isn't too bed with demand, but I've never seen it go for its true value. Correct me if I'm wrong, And I've also been told the Malk has a semi-poor demand. I think your better off with your tiger.

(Please get another opinion)

disagreed.

both pets mentioned have fairly good demand - the UR bee usually goes for fair trade/slight overpay, and the malk has good demand as well - fetches nons from time to time.