The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Desmond]

Me- Joker Dog
Them- Joker Bunny



Me- Gearback Tribal
Them- Nick Unicorn


Are any fair?

The dog/bunny exchange isn't fair, as far as I know. The bunnies aren't valued as much.

I'm not a Tribal expert. :/ Apologies.

EDIT: Which is best for a Sept 08 Rose PPS?

1. Two Grinners (Orange, blue)

2. Trio of store dogs

3. VR August 08 rat

4. Combo of 2 and 3

[Mami_Tomoe]

Gearback
Blue balloon dog
Tess Birthday dog (08)
Floppy eared, pink september
Joker
Yingyan October
Five Advent 08 rats (re-releases)
Blue 'B-day Shadow' cat
Nick sundog PPS
Two jebuary rats
Dark pink B-wolf
Emerald-ish B-wolf
Three Devil dogs (09)
Five Ravenpaw cats
Eat me dog
Drink me dog

for a Sundog w/o jewelry

Hm, I would say unfair as a few of those pets are common. Are the Devil dogs include the PPS version?

[Fiery Gatoh]

Gearback
Blue balloon dog
Tess Birthday dog (08)
Floppy eared, pink september
Joker
Yingyan October
Five Advent 08 rats (re-releases)
Blue 'B-day Shadow' cat
Nick sundog PPS
Two jebuary rats
Dark pink B-wolf
Emerald-ish B-wolf
Three Devil dogs (09)
Five Ravenpaw cats
Eat me dog
Drink me dog

for a Sundog w/o jewelry

Hm, I would say unfair as a few of those pets are common. Are the Devil dogs include the PPS version?

No, just the full grown ones.

[Bulleting Rain]

Gearback
Blue balloon dog
Tess Birthday dog (08)
Floppy eared, pink september
Joker
Yingyan October
Five Advent 08 rats (re-releases)
Blue 'B-day Shadow' cat
Nick sundog PPS
Two jebuary rats
Dark pink B-wolf
Emerald-ish B-wolf
Three Devil dogs (09)
Five Ravenpaw cats
Eat me dog
Drink me dog

for a Sundog w/o jewelry

I would say fair from everything I have seen, specially as the value of July's have gone down. But hey, thats just my opinion. To me there over offering.

[Mami_Tomoe]

Juding by the rarity of the pets listed after the Joker I would say then that it sounds pretty unfair. I mean those pink september dogs they offered and the blue balloon are pretty easy to come by and the Non-Jewel is not.

[Khemo]

Alrightly, here's hoping I'm not going on a scary limb here. >.>;


These three (Two uncommons, one common)

For this:

What I worry about is that the pet I'm trying to trade for is an Oct 08 uncommon, how much are these really worth? I feel like I'm offering too little.

[*~Sharni~*]

Gearback
Blue balloon dog
Tess Birthday dog (08)
Floppy eared, pink september
Joker
Yingyan October
Five Advent 08 rats (re-releases)
Blue 'B-day Shadow' cat
Nick sundog PPS
Two jebuary rats
Dark pink B-wolf
Emerald-ish B-wolf
Three Devil dogs (09)
Five Ravenpaw cats
Eat me dog
Drink me dog

for a Sundog w/o jewelry

I would say fair from everything I have seen, specially as the value of July's have gone down. But hey, thats just my opinion. To me there over offering.

Depends on ones point of view. I know I am not over offering*glares at James* but I don't know if I am under offering.... I have seen people get sorbets for the Balloon and Gearback dogs though.

[Coalchaser]

Gearback
Blue balloon dog
Tess Birthday dog (08)
Floppy eared, pink september
Joker
Yingyan October
Five Advent 08 rats (re-releases)
Blue 'B-day Shadow' cat
Nick sundog PPS
Two jebuary rats
Dark pink B-wolf
Emerald-ish B-wolf
Three Devil dogs (09)
Five Ravenpaw cats
Eat me dog
Drink me dog

for a Sundog w/o jewelry

I would say fair from everything I have seen, specially as the value of July's have gone down. But hey, thats just my opinion. To me there over offering.

Yeah, I agree with you (I thought they might be over offering, too...)
You're getting offered two Augusts, two butterfly wolves that are equal in value to Augusts, two store dogs (which are each about the value of an August), a joker (which tends to go for an August or a common July), several Septembers, and a few other "decent" pets (and I'm guessing that the Ravenpaw cats are there as hoard pets).

So basically, six Augusts, a common July, and a few Septembers for a somewhat uncommon July dog (it is the most common of its litter, so it isn't that rare).

[Desmond]

Which is best for a Sept 08 Rose PPS?

1. Two Grinners (Orange, blue)

2. Trio of store dogs

3. VR August 08 rat

4. Combo of 2 and 3

[Mami_Tomoe]

Oh, store dogs are so NOT equal to the value of an August dog as they are so very easy to trade for and not rare at all. Honestly, I think it is the Sunback that is the most common of the litter and the Non-Jewel is more rare so in my opinion the trade is unfair.