The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[popping star]

May I have help with this offer, please?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ultMDCBLQg
Thank you!

VERY UNFAIR TO YOU BA's go for 2 sorbets

Actually, a BA can also go for 1 sorbet. Demand varies between person to person.
Rarity wise, this is fair as the BA is worth 9 mid advents. Demand wise, this is unfair as the BA can go for more.
Their side is worth 9 mid advents whilst a sorbet is worth 84 mid advents.

[Guest]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... V_PwKWt27w

Is this fair?
I personally value BA’s at about 2 sorbs, are they really going for nons? Any opinions would be AWESOME, as it is my dreamy

True date can go for nons apparently, i traded my ba+pink baloon for a raven (valued at 1.5 nons i believe). But they usually go for 1-2 sorbets

Thanks so much, can I get one more opinion?
I’d just like to be sure!

I agree that they seem to mostly go for a sorbet and some people are willing to offer 2, you would still be overpaying waaay too much if you value them at 2 sorbets

[popping star]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... V_PwKWt27w

Is this fair?
I personally value BA’s at about 2 sorbs, are they really going for nons? Any opinions would be AWESOME, as it is my dreamy

True date can go for nons apparently, i traded my ba+pink baloon for a raven (valued at 1.5 nons i believe). But they usually go for 1-2 sorbets

I agree that they seem to mostly go for a sorbet and some people are willing to offer 2, you would still be overpaying waaay too much if you value them at 2 sorbets

Agreed. Even if you value the BA at two sorbets, you'd be overpaying by a sorbet + blue rose.

[Rotzalot]

Hey! Any advice with this? I just sent it and wanted to know if it’s fair demand wise (for future reference if they cancel haha)
trade

[amaterasu_tea]

is this fair?

thank you in advance <3

[NeatoDudeo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71468196&userid=889143&signature=5fmp141HVSN9dM3vPLITaQ

help???

[dibidibidis]

Could I get some advice on this?
My current long-ish term goal is to trade for the Eat Me/Drink Me, so I'm not sure if it'll be worth trading quantity up when all 3 of the pets I need are at approx. Sorbet-level demand. On the other hand, I know the UR Bee has good (?) demand, and it's worth quite a bit higher than my side, even if I valued my Sleipnir at a Non.
Thank you in advance! ❤️

EDIT: How easily does the Patchwork go for a Sorbet? I know it can, I'm just not sure if that's one of those super-lucky catches or if it's standard demand.
(The trade in question: [XXX])

EDIT 2: How is this demand-wise? Not too sure how the Butterbun's demand is, and I'm not sure how much all 3 (non-Lolita) Punk Dogs can go for.

[FOUND VERDICT]

Hey! Any advice with this? I just sent it and wanted to know if it’s fair demand wise (for future reference if they cancel haha)
trade

seems like an good offer to me.
the orange cerb usually goes for 4-5 nons, and your side is worth 4 nons and 1-2 sorbets (depending how you value the BA)+ an green toxic.
all pets on your side have good/high demand too.

[moon child]

Help ahh Help Please

[Rotzalot]

Hey! Any advice with this? I just sent it and wanted to know if it’s fair demand wise (for future reference if they cancel haha)
trade

seems like an good offer to me.
the orange cerb usually goes for 4-5 nons, and your side is worth 4 nons and 1-2 sorbets (depending how you value the BA)+ an green toxic.
all pets on your side have good/high demand too.

Thank you! Second opinion(s)?