The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[glazend.]

is this a fair trade? I don't trade often

[Candycrystal]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110177137&userid=1097824&signature=aiEgGh3bD-wDx9cGZsMfJQ How does this look? Thank you ^^

this is unfair to you. following the 2:1 rule their side is worth 4 old rares.

your side is worth 7 old rares (valuing the ‘09 rares as 2 old rares each).

your two ‘09 rares would be a fair swap for their two 2010 VRs in my opinion.

Thank you! ^^ I thought that was probably the case but wasn't sure if the 2:1 rule was a hard rule or more like a guideline

[birdiesong]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110177137&userid=1097824&signature=aiEgGh3bD-wDx9cGZsMfJQ How does this look? Thank you ^^

this is unfair to you. following the 2:1 rule their side is worth 4 old rares.

your side is worth 7 old rares (valuing the ‘09 rares as 2 old rares each).

your two ‘09 rares would be a fair swap for their two 2010 VRs in my opinion.

Thank you! ^^ I thought that was probably the case but wasn't sure if the 2:1 rule was a hard rule or more like a guideline

of course!

i’d say it’s more of a guideline as not everyone follows it, but it does seem like a good amount do.

[EmeryAmrik]

Hey guys! This is a bit of a bulkier trade, but I'm terrible at C$ prices, could someone please help me out with this one? Thanks in advance !

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110175757&userid=808369&signature=30J3rkKVKseq0dryAKWeUA

Anybody know things about C$? :')

[Wysterinka]

Hey guys! This is a bit of a bulkier trade, but I'm terrible at C$ prices, could someone please help me out with this one? Thanks in advance !

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110175757&userid=808369&signature=30J3rkKVKseq0dryAKWeUA

Anybody know things about C$? :')

It's hard to count such a huge trade when you don't have the pets priced. I sold most UC pets from year 2023-2020 for 3c$ each, EUC at 4 or 5 and so on. This looks unfair unless you use someone's super cheap price list. But almost any pet can get at least .5 c$ even rhe lowest rarities

[Wysterinka]

Any help with this trade? I know both of them have pretty good demand but im looking for something easy to trade down, would the swap be better for me if i were to trade the PPS dragon down?
EDIT: and this one, thank you

@ghostpants

Idk about demand of that dragon pps but it has very solid 2.5n value. While I had lot of trouble trading my Kirin for 2.5n but eventually did anyway, it just took few months. So I guess it's up to preference but kirin is listed as 2-2.5n range I belive.

[Latibule]

Help? I do believe I'm overtrading, I'm fine with doing a little but the deman for these pets keep fluctuating and i cant keep up lol
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110180648&userid=926807&signature=zYopjGRisd_wcfiuEDygSw

[ACat]

Hi does this seem fair? I was told my side (the store set) is only half the value of their store pet which confused me as I thought the 2020 stores were 0.2 MA. Am I missing something? (Ik the golden gacha has demand it's more the store bit I was confused about)


trades/viewtrade.php?id=110154072&userid=85238&signature=1DCRIsVjcYsWLJQDKFY-iA

[Audrey_Bee]

Hi does this seem fair? I was told my side (the store set) is only half the value of their store pet which confused me as I thought the 2020 stores were 0.2 MA. Am I missing something? (Ik the golden gacha has demand it's more the store bit I was confused about)


trades/viewtrade.php?id=110154072&userid=85238&signature=1DCRIsVjcYsWLJQDKFY-iA

Hey! I had the same thing, I think the user is a bit confused on the values or maybe values their pet differently?

They're store is 2 old rares, and your pets are 1 old rare each so you're overpaying by well over 1 old rare ❤️

[ACat]

Hi does this seem fair? I was told my side (the store set) is only half the value of their store pet which confused me as I thought the 2020 stores were 0.2 MA. Am I missing something? (Ik the golden gacha has demand it's more the store bit I was confused about)


trades/viewtrade.php?id=110154072&userid=85238&signature=1DCRIsVjcYsWLJQDKFY-iA

Hey! I had the same thing, I think the user is a bit confused on the values or maybe values their pet differently?

They're store is 2 old rares, and your pets are 1 old rare each so you're overpaying by well over 1 old rare ❤️

Yeah I thought so 😭 I just wanted to check I wasn't missing something!

I'll send them a message to ask about the values haha ♡