The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[acciobadger]

Help! D8

So I'm holding a UR B-wolf auction, and I've had a good leading offer for a long while.

I just got a new big offer, and I need help figuring out which one is worth more.

Offer 1:

Huskylover - http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts/viewgroup.php?groupid=224098&sid=82b58ea8902bf27e63038bbcc9eb1db8&userid=173

Sorren Fey - Adding to Huskylovers offer:
Yellow Sorbet pup, two different cake dogs + Nick cake dog, pink september, light leopard september, october female striped adult, Christmas 2nd gen parents, ice PPS, boar PPS and you can pick several pre-julies (in my trade rares group beginning on page 22 downwards).

And I'll add to Husky's offer:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=165902
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=139624
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=102823
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=361200
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=394597
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=382769
<3

Offer 2:

joker
ur banana
pink balloon
pink sorbet
uncommon pps
the candy cane necklace dog
the candy cane pps(mine is still a baby)

I am at a slight loss because I have no idea what bananas are worth currently.

The second one is fairer. ^^

[Carm]

Sunback and coon-tail for the UR cat?

[Aloaei]

Sunback and coon-tail for the UR cat?

I think its unfair: My opinion

[Carm]

Sunback and coon-tail for the UR cat?

I think its unfair: My opinion

Meh. They weren't willing to trade anyway. >_<
Thanks, though.

[*~Sharni~*]

Anyone?

Person 1: Red Toxic, Green Toxic, Gearback Tribal

Person 2: White July 08(Growing)


Fair?

[SkySmoke]

Side one: Banana

Side two: gear back tribal and non balloon

[Verd]

X-

[suggestive]

Them: blue toxic pup
me: newborn toxic (it'll be purple or yellow), rare 08 Advent swirl PPS pup, possibly a rare pink 08 Advent or another rare of choice.

Am I paying too much? I think I am, but I really want to complete the set and the only toxic I'm missing is blue. :/

^^?

[Diabolic]

Help! D8

So I'm holding a UR B-wolf auction, and I've had a good leading offer for a long while.

I just got a new big offer, and I need help figuring out which one is worth more.

Offer 1:

Huskylover - http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts/viewgroup.php?groupid=224098&sid=82b58ea8902bf27e63038bbcc9eb1db8&userid=173

Sorren Fey - Adding to Huskylovers offer:
Yellow Sorbet pup, two different cake dogs + Nick cake dog, pink september, light leopard september, october female striped adult, Christmas 2nd gen parents, ice PPS, boar PPS and you can pick several pre-julies (in my trade rares group beginning on page 22 downwards).

And I'll add to Husky's offer:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=165902
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=139624
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=102823
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=361200
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=394597
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=382769
<3

Offer 2:

joker
ur banana
pink balloon
pink sorbet
uncommon pps
the candy cane necklace dog
the candy cane pps(mine is still a baby)

I am at a slight loss because I have no idea what bananas are worth currently.

The second one is fairer. ^^

Okay, thanks :3

Any more opinions? I'd like to be extra sure here.

[clm]

TRADE 1
Them: PPS from last day Advent, PPS lion, both October '08 PPSes



Me: '08 Santa Hat Advent, '08 November Star Stripe dog




TRADE 2
Them: March '09 Tanback Zombie(?) dog, March '09 Green rat, March '09 dark chain rat



Me: '08 Santa Hat Advent, '08 December light brown rat


Unless I'm grossly mistaken, the second is certainly unfair. If that is true, what would be ok to add?

Any opinions on the first trade, at least?
For a Secret Santa recipient, which would you rather recieve?