The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[qhost]

this is ridiculous, I'll show you an offer I got. Not mentioning any names though.

Ok, i wanted to trade for their floppy eared pink sept, and they wanted this from me;

4 pps advents, all different
2 advent rats
3 different novembers
2 valentines day pps
and 2 of the brown march pups that are only allowed to be adopted 8 times

look, i know that dog is uncommon and unavailable, but isn't that a bit much?

So what im asking is, what would be a good offer for a pink sept?

I don't really think that's fair, although that's just my opinion. I think they might be asking too much for it

[Wildstorm]

I know, plus out of the 4 advent pups, they aren't even duplicates! they're my only ones.

[qhost]

I know, plus out of the 4 advent pups, they aren't even duplicates! they're my only ones.

If they're not in your trade group, I don't think it's worth it That might have been worth an August, but not for a September...

[Wildstorm]

Yay! Im glad someone agrees.

[Torchwood~Mindfreak]

Is this the place to post a past trade to see if it was good or not?

well here it is.
I got
for a floppy eared october pup, A january white stripe, and a white spot, a regular robot, a january long tail sketch wolf, a march red PPS, a grown brown auisie, and a growing blue auisie.

Was this a good trade?

[skinklegs]

My
Orange-And-Blue Bobtail (click)

For Their
Fire Malk Dog
Malk Penguin Horse
Malk Skunk Horse
Malk Brown-And-Tan Horse
Hazel Aussie (Growing)

I don't really know, I'm not really an expert on rarities (obviously).

[TrustNo1]

Is this the place to post a past trade to see if it was good or not?

well here it is.
I got
for a floppy eared october pup, A january white stripe, and a white spot, a regular robot, a january long tail sketch wolf, a march red PPS, a grown brown auisie, and a growing blue auisie.

Was this a good trade?

I'd say this was a pretty good trade if the dogs you traded were duplicates.

[Torchwood~Mindfreak]

Is this the place to post a past trade to see if it was good or not?

well here it is.
I got
for a floppy eared october pup, A january white stripe, and a white spot, a regular robot, a january long tail sketch wolf, a march red PPS, a grown brown auisie, and a growing blue auisie.

Was this a good trade?

I'd say this was a pretty good trade if the dogs you traded were duplicates.

Yeah they were.

[roseflight]

I'm new to the whole "trading" thing here; is this any good? I mean besides the fact that it's 3 for 1 (is "spot' rare or something? cuz I kinda like him)
me:

them:

[Solfeggio]

I'm new to the whole "trading" thing here; is this any good? I mean besides the fact that it's 3 for 1 (is "spot' rare or something? cuz I kinda like him)
me:

them:

Erm, Spot isn't really rare, although he is a cute dog. Right now the pets being offered are of equal value to the dog you have so I'd say it's an okay trade, but it depends on how you feel about trading your pet. If you like Spot and don't want to trade him, then don't accept the trade. After all, you can still adopt from the front page all the pets that were offered to you. ;3