The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nyctophilia]

I don't know the demand of my store pet in this trade

[Tumblr.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84964069&userid=961979&signature=p6Yl0aytZ5PRWKaiRhKMAA

Was this fair for me?

Considering that is a Feb. '09 rerelease, id say they overpayed a bit, but that's based on how you value your chicken dollars!

[amarok.]

Is this fair? Idk the demand well for the kitsunes and the dogs on the other side. Thanks!

Also just got this trade for my UR Bengal--was wonder what demand was like for both the Bengal and Joker! Thanks!

Both the Bengal and the Joker can go for around 1.5 nons, but from previous trades I've seen the Joker can fetch 2 nons whereas the Bengal at most fetches 1.5, so imo it's unfair to the Joker. But that's from trades I've seen, so I would wait for a second opinion.

personally i'd actually keep the bengal. the joker is worth considerably less rarity wise and just from what i've seen has less active demand, whereas just today i've seen multiple people seeking out the bengal. that and the fact that i've never personally seen the joker trade for anything more than a non in the last couple of months.

as for the kitsune trade, kitsunes have *ridiculous* demand and I personally think we need to start slamming on the brakes with it. they're only worth 2 '09 rares each as of now so just one t7 advent (some 8-9 '09 rares) is very good overpay. i'd take it personally ^-^

[shogun]

I don't know the demand of my store pet in this trade

Store pets will always be sought after but I haven't seen any particular demand for this set / demand is completely subjective depending on the player. '15 store pet = mid '09 rare, so it's very unfair to the malk side

[maisie+flokez]

Please can anyone help explaining this trade? I'm pretty sure it's still unfair to the UR dog, but I'm not really sure what the demand is for these guys/what they're going for, so would like to understand so I can edit accordingly!

Thank you so much in advance!!

[Kittytalia]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963118&userid=435289&signature=s4NyosYeuJ2rdyCg4pfFtg
Need some help- it's a joker for my BA and the '11 gryphon set

also, how has the demand for both been lately?

[silvermahogany]

Ive been away from CS for a while, im kinda rusty on rarities and demand. Is this any good?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84965757&userid=709911&signature=hrXah6NrSKTNt5CrtZyRXg

Thanka

[Magpie•]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963831&userid=941534&signature=_FbGyBDOKsOm9UQctGWYsQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963902&userid=941534&signature=3qHzEFdOb-gVrMVd-wmxQw
Which one is fair and better?


PLEASE HELP ASAP


BEEN THREE PAGES!

[Madel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963118&userid=435289&signature=s4NyosYeuJ2rdyCg4pfFtg
Need some help- it's a joker for my BA and the '11 gryphon set

It's debatable for sure. The BA can go for anywhere between a sorbet, to a non. It's unlikely someone would trade a non for it, as that's a demand thing. The Joker is worth 1.5 to 2 nons (?). The set on your side has good demand, maybe worth a sorbet. I don't think you'll get a better offer. I'd take it. Get a second opinion though!

[Aremisu]

Hi! I am holding an auction and I was wondering how are these bids? Are they good? Which one is the best? Thank you in advance
- Bid 1
- Bid 2
- Bid 3
- Bid 4
- Bid 5