The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Tumblr.]

Is this a fair trade? Need an answer quickly please!! Thank you so much!!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963524&userid=774759&signature=zZlmWSwmafqlRR-WZhXAKw

Have 2 different answers can I get another opinion quick? Thank you!

[amarok.]

Is this a fair trade? Need an answer quickly please!! Thank you so much!!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963524&userid=774759&signature=zZlmWSwmafqlRR-WZhXAKw

That seems pretty unfair to you, in my opinion.

please don't give poor advice. rarity-wise just the bunny is overpay. the '10 staff dog has some small demand but it's not worth 1.5 '09 rares' worth of pets. with the current demand for store pets i'd say the store pet (worth an early '10 rare but considerably easier to find you could argue) and the staff dog are a perfectly fair swap.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84962584&userid=859213&signature=QHyja2u2CCkchBu-9aMcbg
Hi, is this fair for me? Thanks for help!

the bengal seems pretty popular and goes for 1-1.5 nons whereas the pps usually only fetches one and has considerably less demand. hypothetically it could definitely be seen as a fair swap but personally speaking it's not one i would take.

[unchained]

aaa how's this inc. demand??

[Tumblr.]

Is this a fair trade? Need an answer quickly please!! Thank you so much!!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963524&userid=774759&signature=zZlmWSwmafqlRR-WZhXAKw

That seems pretty unfair to you, in my opinion.

please don't give poor advice. rarity-wise just the bunny is overpay. the '10 staff dog has some small demand but it's not worth 1.5 '09 rares' worth of pets. with the current demand for store pets i'd say the store pet (worth an early '10 rare but considerably easier to find you could argue) and the staff dog are a perfectly fair swap.

Thank you so much for clearing it up! They said they knew it was overpay, but I wasnt sure if that was correct or not, and wanted to double check! Thank you so much!

[Starrzies]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84962965&userid=708655&signature=1zEbSnGrBON0A7XFh6yexQ

I am unsure if this is fair/an overtrade on their part. I am unsure about the lion's original date as well as the wolf on their side. Help?

[maisie+flokez]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84962584&userid=859213&signature=QHyja2u2CCkchBu-9aMcbg
Hi, is this fair for me? Thanks for help!

The UR bengal goes for 1-1.5nons, the July PPS is technically worth around 2, but tends to go for 1 due to bad demand. Technically it's probably around a fair swap, but from what I've seen recently, the bengal seems to have higher demand, so personally I probably wouldn't take that, but it depends which one you prefer.

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84962965&userid=708655&signature=1zEbSnGrBON0A7XFh6yexQ

I am unsure if this is fair/an overtrade on their part. I am unsure about the lion's original date as well as the wolf on their side. Help?

nonononnononomononononono that's very, very unfair to you

the lion gets 1-1.5 nons. their side wouldn't get a balloon dog imo. the cheshire cat and red dragon can both get very good overpay but i've never personally seen one go for more than a couple of advents. please don't accept that.

[Starrzies]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84962965&userid=708655&signature=1zEbSnGrBON0A7XFh6yexQ

I am unsure if this is fair/an overtrade on their part. I am unsure about the lion's original date as well as the wolf on their side. Help?

nonononnononomononononono that's very, very unfair to you

the lion gets 1-1.5 nons. their side wouldn't get a balloon dog imo. please don't accept that.

AGH. TYSM

[loviie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84932523&userid=948873&signature=5nyah6AXihANjGdPtlJWug

o.O this trades been sitting a while I cant figure it out. anyone able to help ? tysm

[➸ ᥙᥒfᥲιr.groᥙᥒds]

Is this fair? I'm still trying to understand rarities on trading

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963615&userid=921030&signature=FK9dcMW2AT9lo7WFuhefXQ