The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Firet]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80375578&userid=732641&signature=L6JyvgozIt4tB4ZDr7CCyg

is this fair?

[Lacelly]

Hi! Is this fair? Thank you
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80391312&userid=154857&signature=f4usb8CQb_OEuG-EGo6mtA

[lucky333123]

Hi! Is this fair? Thank you
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80391312&userid=154857&signature=f4usb8CQb_OEuG-EGo6mtA

It depends on how you value the corgi. It is worth an mid ‘09 rare; however, the demand for it means that you could get more. The zodiac dog tends to go around a late ‘09 rare, but the demand is also super high for this one thus could possibly go for more. Their bwolf is worth two ‘09 rares, so I would say rarity wise it is about fair, but demand wise, I would say it is unfair to you.

[Lacelly]

Hi! Is this fair? Thank you
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80391312&userid=154857&signature=f4usb8CQb_OEuG-EGo6mtA

It depends on how you value the corgi. It is worth an mid ‘09 rare; however, the demand for it means that you could get more. The zodiac dog tends to go around a late ‘09 rare, but the demand is also super high for this one thus could possibly go for more. Their bwolf is worth two ‘09 rares, so I would say rarity wise it is about fair, but demand wise, I would say it is unfair to you.

Thank you! I have been getting a lot of offers for my corgis so I want to make sure I get a good trade for those.

[Lacelly]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80392761&userid=154857&signature=uMWG7RWOHjgQyazmWuDxBw
How is this? I'd want overpay to split the set of lions

[horchata]

kinda taken a break so i'm not familiar with that store pet's demand rn, how's this trade? or at least would you accept it? thanks!

[LittleHalo]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80298075&userid=628538&signature=a3TIllu2s1zNHzCA4kawpQ

Could I get a second opinion on this trade? Im trying to get an UR Lion would this rat help me get one or should I keep what I got?

[nobxdy]

kinda taken a break so i'm not familiar with that store pet's demand rn, how's this trade? or at least would you accept it? thanks!

2013 store pet = 2 '09 rares
You're overpaying by one of the 2019 store pets on your side. ^^
I would personally accept though considering I like the Kitsune more than the store pets on your side, but that's just my opinion.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80392761&userid=154857&signature=uMWG7RWOHjgQyazmWuDxBw
How is this? I'd want overpay to split the set of lions

The 2008 pet on their side was available until August 2009, so it's worth a mid-late '09 rare. The 2015 store pet on your side is worth a mid 2009 rare, so it's about fair.

[Ari!]

kinda taken a break so i'm not familiar with that store pet's demand rn, how's this trade? or at least would you accept it? thanks!

generally, i think people tend to go by the rule of two 2019 store pets equals one 2018 store pet and two 2018 store pets equals a 2017 store pet etc. with your side of the trade that might add up to about a 2017 maybe 2016 store pet so i think their side is overpaying a bit. maybe don't take my opinion cos im not 100% sure but i think you'd be getting the better end of the deal

[witchery]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80393046&userid=698875&signature=DbQZ0nQ58bU4ETQYlQACfg

is this fair..? I just realized I don’t know what the eggs are worth. Bunnies aren’t really my favorite so I’m hesitant.
trade partner if you see this, I’m sorry for making you wait (´°̥̥̥̥̥̥̥̥ω°̥̥̥̥̥̥̥̥｀) I’m not very confident in trading so I just want an outside opinion...