The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Coalchaser]

I asked earlier is a pps july too much for a UR pup?

Er...I'm going to have to say yes, that's too much. On Dec. 18, I adopted the re-release present several hundred times (logged out, of course) to test out rarities and whatnot. I seemed to get an apple twice per 10 adopts, and a UR puppy at least once (if not twice) per 10 adopts, whereas I only got a July '08 white puppy (which is much more likely to be the growing white than the PPS) once per 15-25 adopts. Therefore, I'd say the UR pup really isn't that rare, and certainly not worth a July '08 PPS...

[Wavesong]

Is

for

A fair trade??

o^o no one answered darr

[CallyKat]

I think that this is unfair, but I want other people's suggestions, too on whether this is fair or not-

My side- All three September 2008 pink wolves (no idea what they're called) Tess White wood Winged wolf, and both green and blue July 2008 rat re-release newborns. Total of 6 pets. Go ahead and ask for images if you're not sure what I'm talking about xD

Their side- Apple >.>

[Carm]

Oh heack no, way unfair to you, CallyKat. The apple isn't that rare.

[Coalchaser]

I think that this is unfair, but I want other people's suggestions, too on whether this is fair or not-

My side- All three September 2008 pink wolves (no idea what they're called) Tess White wood Winged wolf, and both green and blue July 2008 rat re-release newborns. Go ahead and ask for images if you're not sure what I'm talking about xD

Their side- Apple >.>

Definitely not fair to you. o.o

Is

for

A fair trade??

o^o no one answered darr

This looks okay to me, but I think you should get a second opinion.

[Tsabhira]

So, the 5 January rainbow tiger/leopard dogs (see my wishlist; I'm not desperate for them) for my two grinners. I'm thinking not fair to me. Opinions?

[TallyHo]

This isn't so much a trade offer, but I'm wondering what's going on. I have a newborn moon dog and I'm getting all these PM's asking me to trade and what do I want for it.
What's the big deal?

It's a re released dog from last year that's pretty valuable.

Well I traded my spare one for 2 ponies, a Reindeer and 4 mini horses. So it looks like the person got a pretty good deal. But truthfully everyone else sent me messages asking me what I wanted for it and I don't have time to go through all their pets and plus I didn't really know if I would ask for too much or not enough.
I think from now on I will run every trade through here until I have a better idea of what I am doing, lol.

[Converse-Freak]

So, the 5 January rainbow tiger/leopard dogs (see my wishlist; I'm not desperate for them) for my two grinners. I'm thinking not fair to me. Opinions?

I would say not fair to you. Grinners are labeled as rare. And those rainbows aren't worth two rare grinners, to me.

What do you think is the most I could get out of this pup:


I have two of them.

[Pastry]

I think you might have over offered.

Sadly, I tried to convince them that while I wasn't interested in the apple, I thought the Green toxic and the dragon egg were enough. (Even if, to insure I'd win, I hunted down a green toxic, seeing how that was the pet they really wanted)

I kinda figured as I was making the trade that I was paying too much, but ehh.
I really wanted this pup, so to me, I'm happy.
Even though I was asking for the pets from my wishlist, when I put my apple up for auction, I knew I wasn't going to get them. Not to mention, I will have plenty of chances to get the sun/moon outcomes later. Even more so now that there is more out there. lol

[Sweetcuddlelemon]

For
Galaxy pup? (noy sure if clear-eyed or dark yet)

Fair or Unfair?