The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Strawberry_dreams]

is this worth it/fair?

unfair to you, most of those items are new or you can buy them in-store.

thank you can i have another opinion please? ^^

I have to agree. There’s nothing really special about any of those items

[little sunshine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92482425&userid=810054&signature=IU5aKdtQz--jbTew4CRYBw helppppp

this definitely doesn't seem fair to you
those items are not worth a lot, so doesn't bridge the gap between their pets and yours

[Strawberry_dreams]

is a joker dog fair for a ur strawberry? demand-wise?

In my opinion it’s not fair. Where yes the joker should go for 1-1.5 nons it usually goes for about 2 nons and so that wouldn’t be a fair trade. I saw a joker the other day go for a CEG, a blue balloon, a T7 and the purple bat dog. So your joker can get more!
But if you are the strawberry and they offered know it’s not fair but you could take it. Just add to your side maybe?

[Nira.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92482425&userid=810054&signature=IU5aKdtQz--jbTew4CRYBw helppppp

this definitely doesn't seem fair to you
those items are not worth a lot, so doesn't bridge the gap between their pets and yours

I agree, it doesn’t seem fair
If we apply the 2:1 ratio:
2 2011 uncommons = 1 2011 rare
2 2011 rares = 1 2010 rare
2019 R = 4 2019 UC = 2 2018 UC = 2017 UC = 2016 C = 2015 VC = 2014 OMGSC (xXx)
2014 R = 4 2014 UC = 2 2013 UC = 2012 UC = 2011 C = 2010 VC (xXx)
15 C$ - depending on personal values can buy you a 2012 very rare or a 2011 rare

Just the 2011 staff uncommons add up to 4 2010 rares using this method
The other staff pets add up to (roughly) 2011 rare and something
While the 2:1 ratio isn’t perfect, clearly it’s unfair to you

[Elkmire]

Would pink balloon, purple toxic, non-swirl moondog, + 187C$ = red cerb?

[Strawberry_dreams]

Would pink balloon, purple toxic, non-swirl moondog, + 187C$ = red cerb?

The cerb goes for 2-3 nons. And with demand it might go for more.

Pink balloon = .5 nons
Purple toxic = .5 nons
Non-swirl= 1 non
The C$ is worth a low advent maybe a MA max

That’s 2 nons I think you can easily get 3 nons for it. So they would need to add a non worth

[Nira.]

Would pink balloon, purple toxic, non-swirl moondog, + 187C$ = red cerb?

The cerb goes for 2-3 nons. And with demand it might go for more.

Pink balloon = .5 nons
Purple toxic = .5 nons
Non-swirl= 1 non
The C$ is worth a low advent maybe a MA max

That’s 2 nons I think you can easily get 3 nons for it. So they would need to add a non worth

I agree with everything but the red cerb part, which I believe is currently going for 3-4 nons (xXx xXx xXx)

[Jojo Bear]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92290340&userid=860974&signature=Gco4Di3_4ckCuyDHMWjMVQ
Thoughts please?

[rogue_rouge]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92415452&userid=673391&signature=NLQ_XY-_HdsHTSzvsU04Sg

Is this fair? I honestly don't like most of these pets and was looking primarily for a 2012 store Cheshire cat + Nick laptop + add

[bean⭒]

is this fair? i know mines a warrior cat so idk ._. lemme know pls and ty
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92477130&userid=711803&signature=ChDFnBOnFsyYNkxoLZmYuQ

unfair to you by a little bit (in my opinion). I've been offered more for WCs because a bunch of people collect them and value them higher but I guess that depends on who you're trading- get another opinion.

thank u!! :3 could i pls get another opinion?