The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Fantelle]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95173917&userid=25079&signature=s4XzPQ1aREw1W5XXSa2vDA

What could I ask for the rare cat? I don't want anything special, it's just that I already have the cats and the horse and I would like to add something from my wishlist to the Trade. However, I am not sure what would be appropriate from the rarity...

this is fair. generally, 3 uncommons = 1 rare (from the same year).

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95255483&userid=595761&signature=1pe7LU5AQWmbsiTiEkxFuQ

Is this a fair trade? Any help is appreciated (:

this is unfair to you. the horse is worth one or two '09 rares, and the foxes are worth a late '10 rare. their side might add up to one '09 or '10 rare.

[Taf900]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95173917&userid=25079&signature=s4XzPQ1aREw1W5XXSa2vDA

What could I ask for the rare cat? I don't want anything special, it's just that I already have the cats and the horse and I would like to add something from my wishlist to the Trade. However, I am not sure what would be appropriate from the rarity...

This is technically fair (most people say 2-4 uncommon of the same year for a rare) but a lot of people also don't like to trade down their rares into uncommons.

So you could ask for a different rare of the same year or some different uncommons if you're okay with trading down

[AwayfromBirdland]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95255483&userid=595761&signature=1pe7LU5AQWmbsiTiEkxFuQ

Is this a fair trade? Any help is appreciated (:

this is unfair to you. the horse is worth one or two '09 rares, and the foxes are worth a late '10 rare. their side might add up to one '09 or '10 rare.[/quote]

Thanks! <3

[abbie.]

does anyone know how much
c$ would need to be added on their side to make this fair?
thank you in advance!

[walks223]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95263776&userid=394620&signature=h8vjjpzO_8_BbKZgAxaf4w

could anyone comment on this?

[Hellsing]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95258981&userid=25079&signature=1SUfhiNlAfZOsc8ti6LhZA

Is this fair?

thank you in advance!

[gentaro]

is this trade fair? I'm not completely sure of the cake dogs worth haha

[Savynn]

Hi there! Would this be fair? Thank you for your time!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95266459&userid=54485&signature=TzoASbeNuZqeIn0j61A0KA

[Crazy Isi]

Hello everybody!

Is THIS fair?

[BigGayDisaster]

(Image heavy) I think I added this up weird, but I want an opinion or two