The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nobxdy]

OOO THIS?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83272739&userid=961979&signature=wKUZ-G3VrB_SjCe-yhsnnw

If you use the list, the Peppermint Bunny would be worth 4-5 '09 rares + '09 uncommon. They're offering the worth of 5 '09 rares, and I'm not sure what the items are worth sorry --

I personally see it as unfair to them because the bunny came out on Easter 2009, so I value it at only 2 '09 rares but that's just my opinion!

[childe]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83273021&userid=749173&signature=0Az5nwhd8LK0310dCJzlJQ
i dont know what anything is worth anymore bc i left for a few months so is this fair

[XxDragonScalesxX]

Could I get some help with this trade?
I'm a bit unsure of the value of all the animal eggs in this trade.

Another trade I'd like to check before I decide on anything.

[madisong]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83273021&userid=749173&signature=0Az5nwhd8LK0310dCJzlJQ
i dont know what anything is worth anymore bc i left for a few months so is this fair

I think it’s actually a real nice offer. I’d value your side at 1.5-2 nons at most.

[Griffin Torrens]

Thoughts?
Warning: bulk for list trade
He's a dreamie so I'm very happy, but was it fair?
Thank you!

[madisong]

Thoughts?
Warning: bulk for list trade
He's a dreamie so I'm very happy, but was it fair?
Thank you!

Unless I’m missing something, it looks very unfair to them. Your side would be equal to maybe 1.5 sorbets at most depending on how you value the lolita.

[Brackensnake]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83273203&userid=781035&signature=IDod7qIhIYNUHKPWNPNqww

Slightly interested in this one.

Opinions of all sort are welcome and I would love to know if it is fair or whether you would personally accept.

[quitting99983]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83273203&userid=781035&signature=IDod7qIhIYNUHKPWNPNqww

Slightly interested in this one.

Opinions of all sort are welcome and I would love to know if it is fair or whether you would personally accept.

Sunjewel is valued at 3 nons at the moment so this is fair if you value bee at 2 nons and raven at 1, but I wouldn't accept the trade as the sunjewel is very hard to trade down fairly and your pets can get a lot better offers individually

[ithiria]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83273203&userid=781035&signature=IDod7qIhIYNUHKPWNPNqww

Slightly interested in this one.

Opinions of all sort are welcome and I would love to know if it is fair or whether you would personally accept.

Sunjewel is valued at 3 nons at the moment so this is fair if you value bee at 2 nons and raven at 1, but I wouldn't accept the trade as the sunjewel is very hard to trade down fairly and your pets can get a lot better offers individually

list wise they are overpaying, but demand wise its unfair to you.
the bee has a good demand and goes for 2 nons+ and the raven goes for more than 1 non, i value it at 2 nons.
( yes, i know its advent only and its huge overpay but from what i have seen it REALLY goes for 2 nons. )
and i totally agree, the sunjewel is hard to trade off, their side 3 nons, your side 4 nons, i wouldnt take it either ♥

[Vilhelm]

Which is best? How can the others improve?
Bid 1

Bid 2

Bid 3