The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Valak]

Can someone please tell me if this trade is fair or not?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110291&userid=450624&signature=gljiDmZClFI3TYxG2C4_3w

your horse is from 2009 and Is a malk which is to some valued at more. I believe it is only worth 2 09" rares. but could possibly be worth three. rats aren't in demand to most users and aren't as easy to trade off as your malk horse\ 09 dogs. I wouldn't accept this trade. I would ask them to change their rares to other species or I would decline. IMO <3

[ducksarestupid25]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97115661&userid=533691&signature=fMfWYh94vtapB8_7JB_NzA

Thoughts on this trade? I'm newly back and not really sure how to account for the year gap - it seems rather unfair to me imho, but I'm not sure if that's just because I'm very partial to the cute goats;; Would really appreciate others' opinions!

[snowdrake]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97115661&userid=533691&signature=fMfWYh94vtapB8_7JB_NzA

Thoughts on this trade? I'm newly back and not really sure how to account for the year gap - it seems rather unfair to me imho, but I'm not sure if that's just because I'm very partial to the cute goats;; Would really appreciate others' opinions!

their side adds up to a tiny bit more than a 2017 uncommon, so this is unfair to you.

[SaltyTrigger]

Hello! Can I get advice on this trade? Wanting to make sure everything is fair! Thank you in advance <3

This is very unfair to the Target dog which goes for about 2 ma (Source). A ma is around 6-9 09 rares. They only have roughly 4.5 maybe 5 if you really care about the sitting cat lineart.

[0BirdMasta0]

Can someone give me advice on this trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97109806&userid=1025473&signature=IshEJW-vCbljPiG7nH6W5A

I'm pretty sure they're very over, and all the pets on their side are on my wl. My only issue is that- well- I don't really want to be trading Chip Belljingles and Thylor, since they're the only copies I have of those outcomes.
I can probably trade for another copy though. Thoughts?

[N64]

How is this ?

[-Frost-]

Is this a fair bulk trade for my '10 rare? Any help is appreciated, thank you!

Can someone give me advice on this trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97109806&userid=1025473&signature=IshEJW-vCbljPiG7nH6W5A

I'm pretty sure they're very over, and all the pets on their side are on my wl. My only issue is that- well- I don't really want to be trading Chip Belljingles and Thylor, since they're the only copies I have of those outcomes.
I can probably trade for another copy though. Thoughts?

With unknown rarities, it's hard to say but I would agree they're probably slightly overpaying for your pets. If you don't want to trade your only outcomes, I would try editing the trade and see if they'd like something else.

[snowdrake]

Hello! Can I get advice on this trade? Wanting to make sure everything is fair! Thank you in advance <3

This is very unfair to the Target dog which goes for about 2 ma (Source). A ma is around 6-9 09 rares. They only have roughly 4.5 maybe 5 if you really care about the sitting cat lineart.

I have to disagree. the 08 extended release warriors appear to get 1MA fairly consistently and the red spotted october is a low advent worth 4-5 09 rares on its own as far as I remember. that plus the rare warrior (2-3 09 rares) makes their side worth pretty much 2MA and is a fair trade!

[Valak]

help needed here!!

is this a fair trade as is? whos pet is more in demand( are they worth the same?) they are very kind and I'd love to work something out as long as I am not losing value in this trade. should I add to their side? is so what should I add? any help is appreciated ❤

[polly pocket]

should i take this offer on my clockwork bunny?
it’s very tempting but i know i’m going to want another clockwork bunny in the future for my collection...
please help! ty in advance:)

honestly, no.
they may be offering a little more than 1.5n in c$ + 0.25n pet-wise
but c$ is rather hard to trade back into high value pets

thank you!
second opinions please?