The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[BillyBoi]

Edit: Cancelled

[BillyBoi]

Hi, is this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=111421820&userid=182352&signature=FAGHyg6zQx80xoKGgQPC9w

This is really really unfair to the avocado, even with the low demand the pet still goes for 5 - 7.5 MA

All their pets together equals doesn’t even equal 2MA it’s closer to 1.2MA I wouldn’t accept this trade their side needs another 3.6 MA to make it to the lowest value of the Avocado

[LilyRoseWater]

Which of these 2 bids would be more fair for my Dachshund store set?

Small variety of rares and very rares

Deer store set

[_SmollJellyfish_]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111423524&userid=1050817&signature=sz7zj-UYhO4J68Ei17MVYg
Any thoughts? I don't know if I should accept >.< Thanks in advance!

[JayBae333]

Hi! I'd love some opinions on this trade! Thanks in advance!

[Supreme]

Hi! Could I get anyone's opinions on this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111423613&userid=702384&signature=erdWkyNcHN-nftwLh2fEmA

[angst]

Hi! I'd love some opinions on this trade! Thanks in advance!

It looks slightly under to me! Your car is worth .5MA I'm pretty sure and their side is less than 5 old rares. If they changed the 2013 rare to something from an earlier date and added another older rare it would be fair I think!

[KookyAlienQueen]

Hi is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111423949&userid=1016753&signature=OEKYi19otlruKEfYc_YCBQ

[angst]

Hi! I'd love some opinions on this trade! Thanks in advance!

It looks slightly under to me! Your cat is worth .5MA I'm pretty sure and their side is less than 5 old rares. If they changed the 2013 rare to something from an earlier date and added another older rare it would be fair I think!

Hi! Could I get anyone's opinions on this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111423613&userid=702384&signature=erdWkyNcHN-nftwLh2fEmA

Wow this is such a wild trade lol!

Hmm. Without doing all the math for the rare and below / the deer on your side and the extras on theirs, it looks like they're offering 2 TD sorbets at 1non-ish for your 1.5nons and guessing that the bulk on your side equals the extra .5non or 50 old rares.

This is really tough. I'm not sure how easy it would be to trade two TD blue sorbets or if you're a TD collector or not, so I hope someone else can weigh in on that.

It seems like this may come to personal preference if you want to trade that much bulk and like the sorbets. It's a great opportunity if you're looking to trade up but their side may have less demand than yours, unsure.

Sorry that's not that helpful haha!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111423524&userid=1050817&signature=sz7zj-UYhO4J68Ei17MVYg
Any thoughts? I don't know if I should accept >.< Thanks in advance!

Oof. The moon dog has confusing worth - hard to tell! I'd suggest looking at the confusing worth thread and seeing what's been traded for it in the past!

I will say the VR malk skull cats occasionally go for as much as .5MA, which makes this a pretty good offer.

It's probably up to you - they're obviously overpaying rarity wise, the rest is subjective. I'm sorry that's not useful, lol!

hi! is this trade fair?

I would suggest removing one of the normal VRs on your side (NOT a zodiac) making both sides 2MA rarity wise. I will say though that, as you probably know, the staff litter is pretty popular and some people have valued their litter dogs as worth more than just an 09 VR. But technically without valuing them more and going based on rarity / fairness, your side is 2.5 old rares over (one 09 VR) for their two store dogs, both of which are 1MA.

[LilyRoseWater]

Which of these 2 bids would be more fair for my Dachshund store set?

Small variety of rares and very rares

Deer store set