The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nafla]

Help please ><

[ShadowStarFang]

Hia! <3

I've gotten a trade on a lovely store pet of mine and was just curious of how fair it was for me <3 Thank you bunches! <3
This Here Is The Lovely Trade
Thank you so much to everyone that helps! <3

[A.skater.Chen]

Hi! Is this fair?? If not, what would roughly need to be added?? And would you personally take it?? Thanks soo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OP-ymgscgQ

[kikufuku]

Hia! <3

I've gotten a trade on a lovely store pet of mine and was just curious of how fair it was for me <3 Thank you bunches! <3
This Here Is The Lovely Trade
Thank you so much to everyone that helps! <3

Hey there! uwu

I believe it's slightly unfair to you rarity-wise, since '14 store pets are worth mid '09 rares, not late '09 rares. It also depends on how much you value the uncommon and commons - they don't have any set values but it may help if you consider the years of them! c:

Demand-wise, I believe it's quite unfair as horses don't have good demand and they're wanting a dog in return. Sure, there's an uncommon dog but it's mainly the rare horse that you should focus on. :c

I hope this could help ya! ♡

[kikufuku]

I was just offered an uncommon and 70 C$ for a few of my rares. I'm bad with the worth of C$, so I need some help...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3r4lEbvwvA

Oosh... ;w; that looks extremely unfair to you, both rarity and demand wise. The rereleased 2nd gen is from '08, and 08' rares are worth roughly 50 C$. The dalmatian, since it's an early 09' rare, is worth 40-45 C$. The zodiac dog though, if going by rarity, is worth 25-30 C$. If going by demand, it's the same worth as the dalmatian (they can go for 09' rares :>). The rereleased Prancer horse is from 09', and it's worth 30-35 C$.

So if we add it all up, they should be offering roughly... 145-175 C$ in total. The uncommon pet doesn't really have a set value, so it depends on what you personally value them at.

I hope this helps ya! ♡ go ahead and get another opinion though, yeah? xwx

[Mewfle]

Hi! Is this fair?? If not, what would roughly need to be added?? And would you personally take it?? Thanks soo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OP-ymgscgQ

They would need to add roughly 2 more midadvents c:

[Raire]

Help please ><

very unfair to the bottom side warrior cats have very high demand

i was wrong on this one wont let me delete itXD

Is this fair? Any help appreciated! <3

unfair to the top

the bottom side is offer rats ect they have bad demand the top has decent demand pets such as the malk cat and pps pupper

[Stormwarden]

hi ! i was wondering if this is fair, and if not, how to make it so? i now know that a '16 store is worth a mid '10 rare, not an '09, but how much/what should i add to make it even?

[A.skater.Chen]

Hi! Is this fair?? If not, what would roughly need to be added?? And would you personally take it?? Thanks soo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OP-ymgscgQ

They would need to add roughly 2 more midadvents c:

Thanks sooooooooo much!!!!!!!!!!
If possible, could I get another opinion?? Thanks again for any help!!!!!

[Raire]

hi ! i was wondering if this is fair, and if not, how to make it so? i now know that a '16 store is worth a mid '10 rare, not an '09, but how much/what should i add to make it even?

i would add a 2013 rare to make it fair it depends on the trader and demand of the pet

Hi! Is this fair?? If not, what would roughly need to be added?? And would you personally take it?? Thanks soo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OP-ymgscgQ

They would need to add roughly 2 more midadvents c:

Thanks sooooooooo much!!!!!!!!!!
If possible, could I get another opinion?? Thanks again for any help!!!!! [/quote]

id have to agree with Mewfle !