The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[xXAngelicWolfXx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111379082&userid=452105&signature=Ba0zdaXByn8dnDe0NyHUfQ
Is this a fair trade? im not sure what the pink UR lion is worth right now :0

[casper.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111376164&userid=833406&signature=8GiqSpXzG4zqNvpzmbc14Q


i’m really really tempted !! how does this look ??

This may need a second opinion, but I'd edit out all of the bottom pets, except for 2 of the '10 store pets. Asking for all of te store pets is grossly unfair to you. It would look more fair with 2 '10 store pets for the store skellybun. I'd be canceling faster than what my fingers could do for clicking. Second opinions are needed here.

second opinion ? x

[⋆✰ Dragon ✰⋆]

Looking for help with this trade!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111362257&userid=997302&signature=fdtl7vKXF-vVDtvomis8GQ

[birdiesong]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111376164&userid=833406&signature=8GiqSpXzG4zqNvpzmbc14Q


i’m really really tempted !! how does this look ??

This may need a second opinion, but I'd edit out all of the bottom pets, except for 2 of the '10 store pets. Asking for all of te store pets is grossly unfair to you. It would look more fair with 2 '10 store pets for the store skellybun. I'd be canceling faster than what my fingers could do for clicking. Second opinions are needed here.

actually using the 2:1 rule isn’t a good idea for high value pets. the skelebun is worth around 8-10 NONs (but a lot of the recent trades value it around 12 NONs). your side includes

seal pps = .75 NONs
orange punk dog = .5 NONs
marionette = 2 NONs
clockwork bun = 1.5 NONs
arabian horses (x2) = .8 NONs (valuing each at 4 MAs)
seahorse (x3) = .6 NONs
carousel horses (x4) = .8 NONs
alien dogs (x2) = .2 NONs
alpacas (x5) = .5 NONs
kitsune = .3 NONs
pps dragoncat = 1 NON
TOTAL = 8.95 NONs

so i’d say it’s actually unfair for the skelebun as it’s valued way higher (horror’s value of 8-10 NONs seems outdated compared to recent trades).

[Vaal Hazak]

Looking for help with this trade!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111362257&userid=997302&signature=fdtl7vKXF-vVDtvomis8GQ

Unfair to them in terms of rarity
these rats usually get half a mid advent, or 3-4 old rares.
depending on how you define an old rare (think it's commonly 2009/2010), your side doesn't really add up to 3-4 old rares

however.
quantity usually gets another via cause nobody is willed to actually trade the exact number of pets that is necessary by going with the 2:1 rule. taking this into account this looks like a quite solid trade; I'd edit out the pink pps lion from 2014 tho.

[jprspereira]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111376164&userid=833406&signature=8GiqSpXzG4zqNvpzmbc14Q


i’m really really tempted !! how does this look ??

This may need a second opinion, but I'd edit out all of the bottom pets, except for 2 of the '10 store pets. Asking for all of te store pets is grossly unfair to you. It would look more fair with 2 '10 store pets for the store skellybun. I'd be canceling faster than what my fingers could do for clicking. Second opinions are needed here.

actually using the 2:1 rule isn’t a good idea for high value pets. the skelebun is worth around 8-10 NONs (but a lot of the recent trades value it around 12 NONs). your side includes

seal pps = .75 NONs
orange punk dog = .5 NONs
marionette = 2 NONs
clockwork bun = 1.5 NONs
arabian horses (x2) = .8 NONs (valuing each at 4 MAs)
seahorse (x3) = .6 NONs
carousel horses (x4) = .8 NONs
alien dogs (x2) = .2 NONs
alpacas (x5) = .5 NONs
kitsune = .3 NONs
pps dragoncat = 1 NON
TOTAL = 8.95 NONs

so i’d say it’s actually unfair for the skelebun as it’s valued way higher (horror’s value of 8-10 NONs seems outdated compared to recent trades).

100% this, actually unfair for the skelebun side.

[Vaal Hazak]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111376164&userid=833406&signature=8GiqSpXzG4zqNvpzmbc14Q


i’m really really tempted !! how does this look ??

actually using the 2:1 rule isn’t a good idea for high value pets. the skelebun is worth around 8-10 NONs (but a lot of the recent trades value it around 12 NONs). your side includes

seal pps = .75 NONs
orange punk dog = .5 NONs
marionette = 2 NONs
clockwork bun = 1.5 NONs
arabian horses (x2) = .8 NONs (valuing each at 4 MAs)
seahorse (x3) = .6 NONs
carousel horses (x4) = .8 NONs
alien dogs (x2) = .2 NONs
alpacas (x5) = .5 NONs
kitsune = .3 NONs
pps dragoncat = 1 NON
TOTAL = 8.95 NONs

so i’d say it’s actually unfair for the skelebun as it’s valued way higher (horror’s value of 8-10 NONs seems outdated compared to recent trades).

100% this, actually unfair for the skelebun side.

the skelebun is one of the few pets where the value does fluctuate a lot and depends on the pets offered.
10-12 seems to be more reasonable, and I'd settle the value of the skelebun at 10n whenever exclusively store pets are offered in return - which is the case here.
compared with other store pet the demand of the skelebun was never that high.

I have to admit that I do not understand some things in the counting above.
aren't the arabians at 0.25n each, thus making it 0.5n? and seahorses / carousels should be 2 ma each, which makes 3 x 2 = 0.5n and 4 x 2 = 8 ma or 0.75n?
so the quantity side is something like 8.25-8.5n?

[CreamyFloof]

Thoughts?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111381178&userid=868350&signature=0pvGBwaG0UymyI21_9kVSg

[BillyBoi]

Hey guys I have 2 trade I need help with! I’m having a hard time counting these 2 up, first one was edited to include more and the second trade has 2 additions to it, any help is appreciated greatly! Thank you

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111350777&userid=1017560&signature=v9gbmf9rFVz9yRJf1StnFA


trades/viewtrade.php?id=111314546&userid=1017560&signature=cNqOYCogopquJClTcfeF0w + addition + addition

I need some help with these bulk trades^.^

^

[birdiesong]

actually using the 2:1 rule isn’t a good idea for high value pets. the skelebun is worth around 8-10 NONs (but a lot of the recent trades value it around 12 NONs). your side includes

seal pps = .75 NONs
orange punk dog = .5 NONs
marionette = 2 NONs
clockwork bun = 1.5 NONs
arabian horses (x2) = .8 NONs (valuing each at 4 MAs)
seahorse (x3) = .6 NONs
carousel horses (x4) = .8 NONs
alien dogs (x2) = .2 NONs
alpacas (x5) = .5 NONs
kitsune = .3 NONs
pps dragoncat = 1 NON
TOTAL = 8.95 NONs

so i’d say it’s actually unfair for the skelebun as it’s valued way higher (horror’s value of 8-10 NONs seems outdated compared to recent trades).

100% this, actually unfair for the skelebun side.

the skelebun is one of the few pets where the value does fluctuate a lot and depends on the pets offered.
10-12 seems to be more reasonable, and I'd settle the value of the skelebun at 10n whenever exclusively store pets are offered in return - which is the case here.
compared with other store pet the demand of the skelebun was never that high.

I have to admit that I do not understand some things in the counting above.
aren't the arabians at 0.25n each, thus making it 0.5n? and seahorses / carousels should be 2 ma each, which makes 3 x 2 = 0.5n and 4 x 2 = 8 ma or 0.75n?
so the quantity side is something like 8.25-8.5n?

just to clarify my values, i referenced horror’s new list which has 1 NON = 10 MAs.
they list the arabians as 3-5 MAs, i valued them at 4 MAs each just to be in the middle. the seahorses are 2 MAs each and the trade includes three of them (i believe even the ER seahorse is still 2 MAs), so .2 x 3 is the .6 NONs. and i listed the carousel set as .8 NONs or 8 MAs.