The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[angst]

I'm not familiar with store pet trading; how does this trade look?

Also; Hosting an auction for my PPS Dragoncat; was curious how these looked?
Bid One

Bid Two

Bid Three <for this bid, I was wondering if the RBM seems to trade well??? If I accept this one, I will actually have the full set. Do people seem to ever actually want a full set?

Bid 1 looks a little under to me but it's close. 2 and 3 seem be to 1non.

Not sure about the RBM, that's a great question! Hopefully someone who's traded with it can respond? My instinct says your second bid may have better demand but I'm unsure.

I may be off though, I hope you get a second opinion!

[squeegi]

does this look fair?

basilisk (3-4 MA) + pps dragoncat (1 non) + joker (2 non) + ur pps dragon (2.5-3 non) = tiger dog (6 non?)
i think it seems about fair, but how does demand factor in? i prefer stores to non stores, but im not sure. would love a second opinion!

[BillyBoi]

Hey guys is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=111339196&userid=1017560&signature=F-c3fe7XvCsPAS0HBOPyQg

[angst]

Hey guys is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=111339196&userid=1017560&signature=F-c3fe7XvCsPAS0HBOPyQg

Oh my gosh my brain hurts from counting this lol! I got closer to 2nons than 1.5, it seems like quite a bit of overpay on their side & that they could take out some of the rares to make it fair.

[BillyBoi]

Hey guys is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=111339196&userid=1017560&signature=F-c3fe7XvCsPAS0HBOPyQg

Oh my gosh my brain hurts from counting this lol! I got closer to 2nons than 1.5, it seems like quite a bit of overpay on their side & that they could take out some of the rares to make it fair.

Thank you so much! I tried myself but I got caught up in the same thing there was quite a bit, I will let them know the value! Thank you again!

[Rhýpp]

Hi! I think I could use some second opinions, the trade is finalized but I'm still curious, was this a fair trade? Warning: extreme bulk! (500+ pets for a TD UR Flamingo) Thanks in advance! <3

[TooSpooky]

is this fair? Thanks

got this bid too

just got this new bid, is it fair? Thanks

[Lawrence Oleander]

Hello! Large amounts of pets are hard for me to keep up with, please weigh in!
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111349061&userid=707183&signature=XPHcYnooxo68Zxpt-OX5WQ

[sour patch.]

is this fair? tysm <3

[angst]

is this fair? tysm <3

Usually no, as the s'mores goes for 1.5nons and the patchwork for 2nons, but perhaps they're valuing the s'mores higher as theirs is a TD? Some people really care about URs being TDs and others don't think it matters at all. I think if you're specifically looking for a TD s'more and are wanting to pay a bit more this may be the trade you're looking for. I think other than that the times I've seen the patchwork go for 1.5nons are for really high demand stores, but that's very anecdotal and just my personal experience!

gl <3