Catsplat18 wrote:What's wrong with putting every single rare on your WL? If you have the patience to go through the entire archive and click that many pets, you deserve to get one from the pound
There's nothing wrong, per se, but big wishlists make trading a lot more difficult. I tend to get overwhelmed and change my mind on trying to initiate a trade with someone when I choose the 'pets on their wishlist' dropdown and it shows I have 2k+ pets they want. Page navigation in the trade window is a nightmare when there's more than 10 pages, I've lost count of the number of times my hand has twitched and made me misclick on the next page number and caused me to start all over! People complain that it's hard to trade nowadays, and this is part of the reason (for me anyway).
There's also the issue where there are different reasons you might wishlist a pet. For instance, I don't like sorbs and don't actively want to trade for one, but when I see a sorb in the pound I still go straight for it because I know it would help me get pets I ACTUALLY want. So I'm torn between having it WL'd for easier pound IDing when images are slow to load, and leaving it off so people don't think I'm looking for one. And you know what else is on my WL? Several uncommons, and (before the rarity update) a common I am hoarding. I don't want to accidentally grab a common hoard pet from the pound instead of a store pet that could be traded for MANY of those common hoard pets (insert Simpsons reference here).