The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[~Misty]

joker bun = non-coon?

whats the demand of both sides worth?

The Joker Bun can go for between 1 and 1.5 nons generally. So depending on how and you partner value it, you are exactly on or a Sorbet off. But most of the time you'll get a successful trade as long as you offer a non or above.

[GreenteaLatte]

Ah I love a fresh new thread.

Anyways, is this fair for a drink-me dog?

My side

So a Drink Me often goes for around 5 - 6 Nons.

How I personally value em:
Dogtag= 2 nons
Marionette = 1 non
Zebra = 2 nons (demand wise)
Joker Bun = 1.5 nons
Joker = 1.5 nons
Rat = 0.5 nons (demand wise)
= 8.5
You are overpaying. Some may value a few of these pets lower, maybe by a non or so. Even then I'd still say you're overpaying xo

Second opinion

Just as a reference this is how I value my pets
Dogtag-1.5
Marionette - 1.5
Zebra - 1
Joker bun- 1
joker - 1.5
rat - 1
So is it fair?

Just wanted to butt in too!

I believe the bottom is..
Dogtag 2 nons
Marionette 1~1.5 nons
Zebra 1 non
Joker bun 1 non (seems to be the easiest omgsr bun to trade off)
Joker 1 non
OMGSR rat 1 sorb

So it would be around 6.5~7 nons c:
I've heard that the Drink me goes for around 5 to 6 nons so I see this as overpay on your side.
Even if you value the OMGSR rat even less than a sorb you would still be overpaying c:

[saint]

opinions?

[pyroklutz]

not sure how to feel about this, opinions?

[Bruno Buccellati]

Would this be fair? >:

[GreenteaLatte]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83883616&userid=224744&signature=BACDlIHw9xhTLeIMT-jvXQ

I know this is very unfair to my side so I'm thinking of offering only one punk dog (not the Lolita). Would it be a decent trade for both sides?
EDIT: I forgot to say I was going to take off the Purple toxic!!

Also, I'm looking for a second opinion on (top) 90 new store dragons for (bottom) White Lolita. Any help would be great.

[greenbunny1998]

They're saying trade unfair to them, is it unfair to them?

[~Misty]

They're saying trade unfair to them, is it unfair to them?

Wrong link x

[greenbunny1998]

They're saying trade unfair to them, is it unfair to them?

Wrong link x

Oops so sorry here's the link

[nobxdy]

They're saying trade unfair to them, is it unfair to them?

Wrong link x

Oops so sorry here's the link

You put a ? mark at the end so I fixed the link for you!
It would be unfair to them, your side is only worth 1 '09 rare + '12 rare
Their side is worth several '09 rares