The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[JJdiner]

Are these two fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76555142&userid=947336&signature=a_cZTT3AMQuqO0n8r3we2Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76555731&userid=947336&signature=PMDuLNtVLoHIzxws7txPmQ

Still looking for an answer + are these ones fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565828&userid=947336&signature=y53X0FSX_Ee6fbEeqzpMfA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565912&userid=947336&signature=l1GqGRtBeTO4YnRgXuOZ-A

for soem reason i can't open the first two, idk why
for the first (of the second two) they are overpaying, and they are still offering dogs, i would take it
for the second i can't tell you what the apple gets with demand, but it is worth 15 MA rarity wise, and their side is only worth:
grinner: (2 MA + early 09 R) (and tends to have bad demand)
cake dog: (6 MA)
total: 8 MA + 3 09 rares so only about half the apples worth

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76562980&userid=774851&signature=65I_1k0Hf7xqW8bFIJm80w

I'm not sure if they added enough or still need to add more to their side. :,,D

Also how is this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565943&userid=774851&signature=8wgqLqRN4-kAuqH7icRTSA

trade 1:
your side: red x = (7 MA or 42-56 '09s):
their side: cake dog = (6 MA or 36-48 '09s):
total 6 MA + 3 '09s + '10 (the zodiac can typically get 1-2 '09s with its demand but how much you value it is up to you)
their side is underpay by about 3-5 '09s (i left out the zodiac cause you can decide how much you value it at and just subtract that to the amount that they should add)

trade 2: very unfair to the other person, the bengal is worth nonballoon tier or Line Tribal + Red Rose but has good demand and i think can get a sorbet, maybe more (check with another person about demand) while the flower pot is worth 2 Sorbets + Green Toxic and i think has bad demand (which again is up to you and the other person) and i think gets about 1-2 sorbs

[bughead]

Thanks!

[FANTASIIIA]

thanks!

[Redpanda]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=76548346&userid=645563&signature=oK5eJsoPHjDnDLw5vlQ2_g

[kkspecial4]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76562980&userid=774851&signature=65I_1k0Hf7xqW8bFIJm80w

I'm not sure of the excact worth of both lists, so i'm not sure if they added enough or still need to add more. :,,D

This is just slightly under for the Red X as the top adds up to 6 Mid Advents + 1 Low Advent.
1 Mid Advent = 6-8 2009 Rares
1 Low Advent = 3-6 2009 Rares

Cake Dog = 6 Mid Advents
3 2009 Rares
Zodiac Dog = Early 2010 Rare (with demand can fetch 1-2 2009 Rares)

Top Side Total Worth: 6 Mid Advents + 1 Low Advent -- valuing the Zodiac at 1 2009 Rare

Red X = 7 Mid Advents

Are these two fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76555142&userid=947336&signature=a_cZTT3AMQuqO0n8r3we2Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76555731&userid=947336&signature=PMDuLNtVLoHIzxws7txPmQ


Still looking for an answer + are these ones fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565828&userid=947336&signature=y53X0FSX_Ee6fbEeqzpMfA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565912&userid=947336&signature=l1GqGRtBeTO4YnRgXuOZ-A

Trade 01:

Unfair to the 2013 Rare.

Bernese Mountain Dog Plushie = Christmas 2015 = 2015 Common/Uncommon
Flurffle = Space Event 2016 = 2016 Common/Uncommon
Birman Plushie to Ragdoll Plushie = Christmas 2016 = 2016 Common/Uncommon each
Peppermint Shake to Bunny Plushie = Christmas 2017 = 2017 Common/Uncommon each
Chick Plushies x3 = Easter 2018 = 2018 Common/Uncommon each

Total Item Worth: a little over 1 2013 Common/Uncommon

They would need to add the worth of another 2013 Uncommon (if you value the items at 1 Uncommon each and you value Rares at the 2:1 ratio) or they would need to add the worth of 3 more 2013 Uncommons (if you value items at 1 Uncommon each and Rares at the 4:1 ratio).


Trade 02:

Slighlty unfair to the bottom.
The 2018 Store Pets are a fair swap - the commons and the staff liter pet are not necessary.

Trade 03:

I believe this is mostly fair. As the combination of the Early and Late 2009 Rare plus the Early 2010 Rare should balance out to the Mid 2009 Rares.

Top Side Worth: 1 Early 2009 Rare + 1 Late 2009 Rare + 1 Early 2010 Rare
Bottom Side Worth: 2 Mid 2009 Rares

Trade 04:

Unfair to the UR Apple by 7 Mid Advents.

Grinner = 2 Mid Advents + 1 Early 2009 Rare
2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares
Cake Dog = 6 Mid Advents

Top Side Worth: 8 Mid Advents + 1 Low Advent (Tier 1 Advent)

UR Apple = 15 Mid Advents

[sillies]

this? thank you in advance!

[Necrøzma]

are these fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565929&userid=819660&signature=nIzSLWmEdeF3IrvOPpq3Vg
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565964&userid=819660&signature=_ObiePzE0G2gZIPSf_Cg4w
Thank youuu :3

[JJdiner]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565929&userid=819660&signature=nIzSLWmEdeF3IrvOPpq3Vg
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565964&userid=819660&signature=_ObiePzE0G2gZIPSf_Cg4w
are these fair?
Thank youuu :3

trade 1:
your side: tier 5 = 6-7 09 Rares
their side: tier 1 (3-4 09 rares) + 2 = 5-6 09 rares
just fair

trade2: their side is 5 09 rares (4/5 are extended releases from 2008 but only go for 1 09 rare because of the extended releases)
unfair to you

Any estimations of how many of the same cat would be needed to equal the UC rat? or make the trade more fair.

@Gasoline

128
1 '10 uc = 2 '10 c = 4 '11 c = 8 '12 c = 16 '13 c = 32 '14 c = 64 '15 c = 128 '16 c

[Necrøzma]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565929&userid=819660&signature=nIzSLWmEdeF3IrvOPpq3Vg
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565964&userid=819660&signature=_ObiePzE0G2gZIPSf_Cg4w
are these fair?
Thank youuu :3

trade 1:
your side: tier 5 = 6-7 09 Rares
their side: tier 1 (3-4 09 rares) + 2 = 5-6 09 rares
just fair

trade2: their side is 5 09 rares (4/5 are extended releases from 2008 but only go for 1 09 rare because of the extended releases)
unfair to you

Thank Youuu!

[kkspecial4]

this? thank you in advance!

Fair - it falls within the worth of the Lilac Bun.
Up to you if you prefer the Tier 1 Advent or the Store Pets.

Lilac Bun = Tier 1 Advent = 3-4 2009 Rares

2016 Store Pets = 1 Early 2010 Rare each
2017 Store Pets = 1 Mid 2010 Rare each

Bottom Total Worth: 3.5 2009 Rares

Uhh, I'm not sure, if this the right thread for my question, since the trade involves an item that I've paid chicken dollars for. The other threads didn't seem to quite fit either, though..so, sorry if I should have posted my question elsewhere!
It's only about one item and three Uncommon pets, so I'm not sure, if this is worth your time, lol. -.o-

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76565788&userid=927312&signature=oQAF1ZAhtBEm30gAjCV99Q

It looks good on first sight - on the other hand I'd have to spend 5 Chicken Dollars to get the eye again and I have no notion, if the three uncommons are worth that much - or worth more than that.

Unfair to the item.

*Uncommons and below do not have a set C$ value and can vary.

2018 Uncommon = less than 1 C$ each

If you value a 2018 Uncommon at 0.5 C$ each the top side is only worth 1.5 C$.
If you value them at less than that then the total value is even less than 1.5 C$.

They would need to add more.

[ C$ Value Guide - second post has guidelines for Rares/Uncommons that are helpful ]