The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Celestial]

My side: Jewely sundog

Their side: July PPS, Common Floppy Eared Moon, Yellow Sorbet, Blue Toxic, Yellow Toxic, Pink Balloon, September Pink Cake Dog, Red rose, Blue rose, Rose PPS, Red Target, Red X Growing, 20 Octobers (full set!)

Sound fair to me. The July PPS is worth quiet a bit and all the other dogs aren't bad at all to get for a jewelry sun.^^

Really? Hmm, I think it's not much... Isn't it more fair if I ask her to add a non-racoon (I need that one so badly)?

[Minimanta]

Sure, you can always ask for more^^ I do consider that offer as a minimum offer. If there wasn't a July PPS or any of the other July/Augusts 08 I wouldn't consider it very fair. If they have a non-coon and are willing to include it in the offer then add it =3

[Celestial]

Sure, you can always ask for more^^ I do consider that offer as a minimum offer. If there wasn't a July PPS or any of the other July/Augusts 08 I wouldn't consider it very fair. If they have a non-coon and are willing to include it in the offer then add it =3

Thank you! =D

[Shian]

My side: Jewely sundog

Their side: July PPS, Common Floppy Eared Moon, Yellow Sorbet, Blue Toxic, Yellow Toxic, Pink Balloon, September Pink Cake Dog, Red rose, Blue rose, Rose PPS, Red Target, Red X Growing, 20 Octobers (full set!)

Sound fair to me. The July PPS is worth quiet a bit and all the other dogs aren't bad at all to get for a jewelry sun.^^

Their side: Cloudstar, 2 new horses from this month
My side:
Message: TRADE WITH ME! I WILL RAISE THE DEAL!!

Unfair to them. No warrior cat are worth two horses and another warrior cat. Warrior cat for warrior cat will make this trade fair =3

Woah! Hold on!

For the sundog, that is a good deal. Usually the Sundog goes for the July PPS and maybe a common moon to make up for the slight rarity, but July PPS is one of the "Top 4"

Lucy, that is an unfair trade to them. Cloudstar you only got two of. The white with black feet people had hundreds of spares. Yes, there are Warrior cats worth two horses and another cat, but it is the other way around. Leopard, heather and cloud everyone only got two of. The other current cats, four.

[Celestial]

My side: Jewely sundog

Their side: July PPS, Common Floppy Eared Moon, Yellow Sorbet, Blue Toxic, Yellow Toxic, Pink Balloon, September Pink Cake Dog, Red rose, Blue rose, Rose PPS, Red Target, Red X Growing, 20 Octobers (full set!)

Sound fair to me. The July PPS is worth quiet a bit and all the other dogs aren't bad at all to get for a jewelry sun.^^

Their side: Cloudstar, 2 new horses from this month
My side:
Message: TRADE WITH ME! I WILL RAISE THE DEAL!!

Unfair to them. No warrior cat are worth two horses and another warrior cat. Warrior cat for warrior cat will make this trade fair =3

Woah! Hold on!

For the sundog, that is a good deal. Usually the Sundog goes for the July PPS and maybe a common moon to make up for the slight rarity, but July PPS is one of the "Top 4"

Lucy, that is an unfair trade to them. Cloudstar you only got two of. The white with black feet people had hundreds of spares. Yes, there are Warrior cats worth two horses and another cat, but it is the other way around. Leopard, heather and cloud everyone only got two of. The other current cats, four.

I mean the Jewely sundog ^^

[Wishful Thinking]

would a white sortic swapped for a purple be fair - they are roughly the same rarity arent they?

thank you!

Jo

[owlcoholik]

would a white sortic swapped for a purple be fair - they are roughly the same rarity arent they?

thank you!

Jo

Pretty much.
All the sortics have roughly the same rarity. Some are just a bit rarer then others ^__^

[~Kaleidoscope~]

would a white sortic swapped for a purple be fair - they are roughly the same rarity arent they?

thank you!

Jo

Pretty much.
All the sortics have roughly the same rarity. Some are just a bit rarer then others ^__^

Actually, that's a bit unfair. The white sortic is the uncommon of the litter, and the purple's more common.

[MusicEmily]

would a white sortic swapped for a purple be fair - they are roughly the same rarity arent they?

thank you!

Jo

Pretty much.
All the sortics have roughly the same rarity. Some are just a bit rarer then others ^__^

Actually, that's a bit unfair. The white sortic is the uncommon of the litter, and the purple's more common.

I thought purple was rarest. I saw more "seekig purple sortic" threads then white ones.

[Celestial]

would a white sortic swapped for a purple be fair - they are roughly the same rarity arent they?

thank you!

Jo

Pretty much.
All the sortics have roughly the same rarity. Some are just a bit rarer then others ^__^

Actually, that's a bit unfair. The white sortic is the uncommon of the litter, and the purple's more common.

I think the purple is more rare ^^