The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jprspereira]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111531426&userid=1092304&signature=zUvURDNTZxQOGz0fwhHEpg


First time bidding on a high value pet, is this fair on my side?

Actually unfair to them. You're offering roughly 6MA of value for a 25MA pet. So your side is like 4 times less.

[Dogjelly]

I am lost when it comes to item rarity (pets for item trade) so any help with this trade is very appreciated!!
This trade!!

[12D3]

can anyone help? a 2010 rare and very rare and 5 C$ for multiple more recent uncommons and commons

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111534944&userid=372624&signature=GQprI56kw6RJ07X_YlfQRg

[Lesbainwolf]

can anyone help? a 2010 rare and very rare and 5 C$ for multiple more recent uncommons and commons

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111534944&userid=372624&signature=GQprI56kw6RJ07X_YlfQRg

wouldn't that be really unfair to them? thats a lot of overpay on there end just for uncommon and commons,

[Andgora]

can anyone help? a 2010 rare and very rare and 5 C$ for multiple more recent uncommons and commons

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111534944&userid=372624&signature=GQprI56kw6RJ07X_YlfQRg

it’s very unfair to them

[teariffic]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111525705&userid=925970&signature=864bsjVIQXLJATpuVTM-Og

hi ! thoughts on this? 2016 r for a 2018 vr

[Dogjelly]

I am lost when it comes to item rarity (pets for item trade) so any help with this trade is very appreciated!!
This trade!!

[Rissebisse]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111533619&userid=892554&signature=mIDujy5YfS_rrxWN6ZM8gg

I’m quite tempted by this trade but am completely out of my depth when it comes to high value pets. Would this be considered a good offer for the kitsunes?

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111533619&userid=892554&signature=mIDujy5YfS_rrxWN6ZM8gg

I’m quite tempted by this trade but am completely out of my depth when it comes to high value pets. Would this be considered a good offer for the kitsunes?

They need to add in my opinion. A full kitsune set is worth at least 1 non (10-12 ma) imo (separately are 2.5-3 ma). White Malk Dragon is 0.5 non I believe and 400c$ is somewhere around 1-1.5 ma.

[angst]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111533619&userid=892554&signature=mIDujy5YfS_rrxWN6ZM8gg

I’m quite tempted by this trade but am completely out of my depth when it comes to high value pets. Would this be considered a good offer for the kitsunes?

They need to add in my opinion. A full kitsune set is worth at least 1 non (10-12 ma) imo (separately are 2.5-3 ma). White Malk Dragon is 0.5 non I believe and 400c$ is somewhere around 1-1.5 ma.

I think so too. I will add though that it looks like their dragon is a true date from 2009, they may be valuing it at 2x the value at 1non. I think it depends if both players value true dates differently!

(Even if both players value the dragon at 1non I do think their side adding .5-1MA at the least would be helpful here).