The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Elwynie]

✰ bid one
✰ bid three

are these fair???

imo.

the first bid seems to be more fair than the 2nd.
the rose pps trades for 3 - 4ma.
The grinner is worth 2 ma while the RR silver advent is worth 1ma (i am not sure about the items)

1 ma in c$ is 350.
So the 2nd person is offering less than 2 ma worth in c$
3 or 4 ma in c$ would be around 1050 to 1400

grubbs

[.near]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111528517&userid=1108929&signature=VSUftN-hAqOZvVdiBDnACg
fair?

[Shiruya.]

If I take out the duplicate chickens, is this fair?

The 2023 Store Pet equals 1 old Rare. The rest is unfair to you considering there's a handful of ER dogs on your side and what they're offering doesn't add up to to make this fair to you -especially if you leave out the duplicates!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111525448&userid=985927&signature=co2P_1yvpFvRW6DtyLkgSw
is this fair? i'm very bad with worths and im not sure how much this omgsr pet is worth

According to horror's list:
09 UR Dog (high tier 3) = 0.5 Non = around 1000-1500C$.
The Ravenpaw rare Warrior add equals 0.5 MA. So if this is what you're looking for I'd say this is not a bad trade!

Hi everyone! Would like opinions on this trade for my Eros please!
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111523538&userid=1093047&signature=HSafUM08PAc7pY4kA-BtxA

Eros usually seems to go for 0.5-1MA (or 5-10 old rares) nowadays.
The red malk fairy should be worth a 09 rare.
I'd say they're slightly under but there's definitely a second opinion needed here!!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111521058&userid=393906&signature=HxLT1I5eN-SnCd6hvJ0gAg heyy any help with this one? not sure how store pets rarities are

also need help with this one. tysm ! trades/viewtrade.php?id=111522814&userid=393906&signature=W2WOISxPb8ZYKqJrpw6fGg
edit : this 1 too ! thank u so much ahead of time trades/viewtrade.php?id=111526377&userid=393906&signature=14H-PptTbnXANjOG0qLtaw

According to horror's list:
Store Seahorse = 2 MA
Kirin/Koi PPS = 0.5 MA / Red Panda = 1 MA
Short by 0.5 MA

Rainbow Corgi = 1.5 MA
MA Kirin/Koi PPS = 0.5 MA / Earth Dragon Cat = 0.5 MA / Green Dragon PPS = 0.5 MA
This is fair!

I'm too unsure about the trade for the Joker to say anything about it unfortunately!

Hi all, I would like some opinions on this trade, thanks!

Each Store Feather Dragon is worth about 3-4 old rares.
I'd say this is overpay on their side - I don't think the foxes have any high/ special demand other than collector's demand for them being event pets on malk fox lines. Second opinion welcome here!

[2kcarat_gold]

✰ bid one
✰ bid three

are these fair???

bid four

just got this one! is it fair?? more or less than the other two??

[toxxic]

Is this fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111528630&userid=83197&signature=KazbuJ2wIcz7ALvfoikWqA

[♡ foxes in socks ♡]

how is this for the rose pps?

thank you so much in advance for any help! <3

[♥♥janiel♥♥]

Bump

[tattoo'ed]

✰ bid one
✰ bid three

are these fair???

imo.

the first bid seems to be more fair than the 2nd.
the rose pps trades for 3 - 4ma.
The grinner is worth 2 ma while the RR silver advent is worth 1ma (i am not sure about the items)

1 ma in c$ is 350.
So the 2nd person is offering less than 2 ma worth in c$
3 or 4 ma in c$ would be around 1050 to 1400

grubbs

Just a quick note that pets are often valued not in their ma value once they hit 0.25n (which the rose pps is). 600-750 is expected for 0.25n. 1000-1200 for 0.5n, 2000+ for 1n and so on. If it was per ma we'd have 1n pets going for 3500, 2n for 7000, which is astronomical and not the case.

Although everyone trades definitely, sticking to horrors list (since you mentioned the ma values they lay out), it's fair to assume that lists c$ value guidelines apply.

[Dogjelly]

I am lost when it comes to item rarity (pets for item trade) so any help with this trade is very appreciated!!
This trade!!

[toxxic]

Is this fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111528630&userid=83197&signature=KazbuJ2wIcz7ALvfoikWqA