The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[arcticbreeze]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7yFcloKkJg
How is this, thank you!

[blonded]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71366621&userid=883464&signature=Li-eo3G1MhUeGKi-fIAxAQ

Should I auto? Is this a very good bid?

[dibidibidis]

Is this fair?
Not sure how much the Nick Cake is worth. ;v;

[nobxdy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71366621&userid=883464&signature=Li-eo3G1MhUeGKi-fIAxAQ

Should I auto? Is this a very good bid?

80C$ = Tier 6 Advent List. They're overpaying with that alone. However, not everybody likes trading their rares for C$. What you do with the trade is up to you to decide.

[PenguinQueen]

Which would be a better offer for my UR zonkey demand-wise?
Trade 1 (non+UR aussie) or Trade 2 (UR bee)?
Thank you, any opinions would be greatly appreciated c:

[avanhellica]

Hi there, is this fair!
[x]
Thank you!

I'm on the other side and would also like to know please ^^

[Dryadalis]

i've looked around a couple of threads and can't seem to find the answer, at what point can you trade a common into an uncommon? so like would a 2010 common be a fair swap for a 2013 uncommon? sorry if that doesn't make sense c:

edit: also the same question for an uncommon into a rare

[Silverstar]

Hi there, is this fair!
[x]
Thank you!

I'm on the other side and would also like to know please ^^

'13 store pet = early '09 rare, so unfair to bottom by 1-2 '10 uncommons.

[Qrawrcorgi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1PNd3mMJyA
good or am I asking a bit much

[Silverstar]

i've looked around a couple of threads and can't seem to find the answer, at what point can you trade a common into an uncommon? so like would a 2010 common be a fair swap for a 2013 uncommon? sorry if that doesn't make sense c:

edit: also the same question for an uncommon into a rare

two commons add up to an uncommon and a '13 uncommon is only worth a '12 common. Four '13 uncommons would be needed for a '10 common.
A rare is valued at four uncommons from the same year.

I've set up some examples on this thread:
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=3657267&p=114473967&hilit=Set+up#p114473967

The store pet value guide is little out of date, though.