Is this a Fair Trade? (Dec 18th edition)

[depressedanonymous,]

I need advice on 2 trades this time around, haha!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85493486&userid=968566&signature=_NINlFyeDAMi3mQC7iTAKQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85493445&userid=968566&signature=VyZ3p0hqszu3tGXIYEjpvQ


On top of that, someone else is also messaging me to see if they can gather pets I might like!! Any advice?

Edit: Also, what does 'ex list pet' mean?

Ex list means that when the list was still in use, this pet was on it. The list is discontinued now as it was very out of date <3

Both are unfair, the 1st being INCREDIBLY under for your cat, the 2nd being worth about 1/2 the cat

[SpiritX]

Are any of these fair? New player here trying to figure out 18th December logic -w-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85451949&userid=981441&signature=YqT_VPgkufpQA-b2QeWniA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85482500&userid=981441&signature=AeLVy1SUuSkoMvfTVqzRjQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85485209&userid=981441&signature=-tAR3WYKqOPbBorTQfzN_w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85485209&userid=981441&signature=-tAR3WYKqOPbBorTQfzN_w

Been told the first two are good offers and are even! But I received a n o t h e r trade QwQ Looking for several opinions!

[K_Rayne]

Please help! I really need to know if this is a fair trade.
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85494103&userid=808935&signature=1bYNxKhhijPxJKXU2FITtg

Also, does anyone know if a ur squid for a coontail is fair?

[EmilineRose]

is this fair? If not what would make it fair?

[Harlowe]

How about this? I joined in Jan and haven't had many old pets to trade so I really don't know.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85496423&userid=956330&signature=HFL044uYE50FANo98IwL8Q

[Flicka]

ok, these are from the same person but slightly different.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84307528&userid=9355&signature=JhDv3hhgpig0P86mdGaDdQ
&
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84503245&userid=9355&signature=MK2z-P4szYRseUCL5M1atQ

Are either fair? This is an old 18th pet ^-^;

[TheGodOfDestruction]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85497687&userid=967329&signature=Xapg3cTmW7NdVgM2rKFe3g

Fair? Help asap please!

[Ishuna]

Alright, another one!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85493570&userid=968566&signature=Vw0tTDCZ7dDvTb5FWgM_kg
This one is editable only (So I can't accept as is)- I kinda like it, but I'd prefer more (And they have some store pets I could ask for). Thoughts?

[lucifer morningstar]

ok, these are from the same person but slightly different.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84307528&userid=9355&signature=JhDv3hhgpig0P86mdGaDdQ
&
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84503245&userid=9355&signature=MK2z-P4szYRseUCL5M1atQ

Are either fair? This is an old 18th pet ^-^;

both look unfair to you unless I've missed something. your cat is from early '09, making it worth two early '09 rares. neither one seems to add up to that. I'd get a second opinion to be sure though.

[Albino_]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85501047&userid=753118&signature=tUn2uLClmsBeBqxgdfOIiQ

What can I add to make this fair? I have the holly dog and target dog.. would any of that be worth the pet I'm trying to get?