Okay, I'm a sucker for older games so I play old Final Fantasy's that are, wait for it - pixelated. Everyone seems to be obsessed over 14 and 15, but a lot of good storylines and characters are in the older games, such as Final Fantasy 8.
Well I've become a harry potter addict. I started playing the prisoner of azskaban game again from 2004. I don't believe many people even remember this game so, i think it qualifies.
I'd say it's Façade. I enjoy it, it's fun, but people could say it's got awful graphics, it's old, there are way better games than this. But this one is just wonderful and I love it.
a lot of people seem to dislike Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel? i've never really understood why though it's probably my favorite out of the whole series haha